- This topic has 7 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 2 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
PHi folks
Apologies for the long post, but it is crucial to us as the public.
Bit of background before the actual question:
So I am a National Compliance Manager at a Fortune 500 subsidiary in India. The company manufactures/assembles and sells almost all components associated with a petrol pump, such as dispensers, nozzles, hoses, the POS systems, and all the internal hardware that goes in there.
Our customers are a who’s who of major national oil marketing companies (OMCs), as well as major names in the private sector too.
The system:
The POS systems are protected from being tampered in the field (the physical pump where the system is installed) by a system that is inaccessible to the customers (OMCs) or the staff operating the pumps. This system can only be accessed using special physical keys and even after that there is an OTP required which only we can receive as registered OEMs.
Now the issue:
A month ago we discovered that one of our customers (major national OMC) is facing a legal challenge from their customer (someone who usually fills up their vehicle at that particular gas station). The customer has alleged that there is major tampering going on as the fuel dispensed shown on the POS module does not match the indicator on his dashboard, neither does the amount being billed vis a vis the volume of fuel dispensed.
The kicker:
On conducting a field inspection it was found that the so-called impenetrable POS module was not really so. The pump operators were tampering with the pulsers inside and thus the readings were off. This was at one site, we have over 4,000 locations where our products are installed across the country.
The ask:
My company, despite raising this matter to the highest echelons, is deaf and is not bothered to take action. But I know for a fact that millions of us fill up our vehicles everyday. Considering this as a national issue, I would like to pass this information to either the media or a government ministry or agency that would take heed of this issue and begin a troubleshooting process or take legal/pumitive action.
Please suggest further course of action that I can take, I do not care about the fallout/backlash I might face because of this, I have had it with their dismissive attitude.
Thank you in advance and apologies again for the long post.
-
BWhat you are dealing with involves serious legal concerns that affect not just your company but the broader public. If tampering is occurring in fuel dispensing systems, it raises legal concerns under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, the Legal Metrology Act, the Consumer Protection Act, and possibly even the Competition Act, depending on the scale and impact. These are serious legal violations because they involve misleading the public in essential transactions.
The Legal Metrology Act mandates accurate measurement in commercial dealings. If fuel dispensers are being manipulated through internal hardware like pulsers, that would directly violate the standards for weights and measures. It is not necessary for the customer to prove intent at every outlet. The presence of a vulnerability and its exploitation by pump operators is sufficient to trigger regulatory action, especially if the manufacturer has knowledge and does not act.
The Consumer Protection Act prohibits unfair trade practices, including the sale of goods using deceptive methods. If consumers are consistently receiving less fuel than what they are charged for, and the system is designed or allowed to function in a way that enables this, there is a clear basis for consumer complaints and regulatory inquiry. If this affects many petrol pumps across the country, it is not just a private grievance but a public harm.
If your company is aware of the vulnerability and has not taken corrective measures, it could also attract scrutiny under the Competition Act, particularly if this affects market integrity or gives an unfair advantage to certain suppliers or retailers. Allowing faulty or manipulable systems to remain in circulation without disclosure can amount to an abuse of dominance or collusive conduct in some circumstances.
It is good that you are thinking of approaching the authorities, but it is important to do this carefully. Your position inside the company gives you access to critical information, but it also puts you at risk of professional retaliation. While the law recognises the right to report wrongdoing, you should ensure your disclosures are made in good faith to a public authority, not to the media or the public at large. The Legal Metrology Department and the Department of Consumer Affairs are two appropriate bodies to receive such complaints. Both have the power to inspect, investigate, and take enforcement action.
If the issue is widespread and involves large-scale consumer harm, a public interest litigation before a High Court may also be appropriate. That would require evidence, framing the petition in the public interest, and carefully presenting your role to avoid personal risk. Courts have intervened in similar cases where consumer rights and regulatory oversight were at stake.
If you are serious about taking this forward, I can help you assess the best legal route and prepare the necessary documentation, including communications to regulators or court petitions, while protecting your position throughout. Let me know if you would like to discuss this further.
-
Pfinally! a sane response after weeks of stress! can’t thank you enough.
i am trying to highlight exactly what you put succinctly, literally facing ridicule and suspicion on other subs for this.
anyway, it IS nationally important and needs to be brought to the right authorities because I know for a fact that the OMCs or our company will never ever do it. also the faulty machines are literally running everywhere while these guys “appear” to find a solution.
-
-
-
Pmy pleasure, please spread as much as you can and ask the folks around you to be extra vigilant at gas stations
-
-
-
AI swear to god i have been thinking there has to be tampering going on. The mileage of the vehicle, even a two wheeler, fluctuates drastically every fill. Either they are adding up more ethanol than allowed or dispensing less fuel. Consumer is screwed from all corners.
-
-
