- This topic has 75 replies, 45 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 2 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
CA maid that works near me got detained by police for the deportation order that recently was issued. She was arrested for being a citizen of Bangladesh, but she was born here in India and solely got arrested for living with here friends who were bangladeshi. She has all documents to prove that she is Indian. She has now spent around 1 and a half month behind bars with here 4 year old child which is held for same reason. The police at the jail at which she is held is exploiting her because she isn’t educated, they have taken around ₹50k for ‘bail’ but after they got the money they ignored her and now are asking for more. I request someone with proper knowledge about this matter to kindly help us and get her snd her child out.
-
QYou can apply on her behalf in local court of jurisdiction for bail. If they decline, approach HC. And write letters to HC, CM and PMs etc, nothing will happen, unless this issue gets highlighted. These applications can be without lawyer or some probono lawyers from the legal cell.
In lands of poor, police is Mafia.
This Idiocracy of labelling people Bangladeshi or other nationality must be stopped, police should deport anyone after thorough investigation. I know it will never happen.Moreover, I am finding it rising trend of “Dehumanizing” certain nationalities and religions. People are losing their sensitivity. Just another political drama to distract attention from the core issues.
-
-
-
MMay be some good Samaritans can open their houses to save poor people from dehumanisation. Bangladeshis have full rights to live here and do everything. That would be really helpful if secular and liberal Hindus can open their farmhouses and avail residential facilities to Bangladeshis.
-
-
-
-
V>Bangladeshis have full rights to live here and do everything.
Really? Do you know how countries and citizenship works? Do you know how immigration works? Do you know how economies work?
>That would be really helpful if secular and liberal Hindus can open their farmhouses and avail residential facilities to Bangladeshis.
How many are you hiding? This is seriously a messed up way of thinking. Wtf is anyone supposed to house illegal immigrants?
-
-
-
RWill get downvoted for this. But ask her to go back to Bangladesh with whoever her illegal migrant friends are.
-
-
-
LLmao the downvotes log bhut chutiya hai apne
Downvote karne wale sbb wahi madarchod hai joo usa ki tarif krr rahe the jbb wo illegal indian immigrants depot krr raha tha
-
-
-
RTo all those downvoting me as well as you lord calling me a dumbass.
Please understand that she was involved in harboring illegal immigrants despite knowing the fact that they are illegal immigrants. She’s as much a terrorist to me as are other illegal immigrants.
Plus even if she is born here does not mean her origins are Indian. Having documents is one thing but harboring or involving with Bangladeshi illegals is another.
Which is why – she and her bangla friends can go back to bangladesh.
-
-
-
-
RDownvoters and liberals are one of the biggest dangers our country is facing. They will fight for illegal kanglus but won’t speak a word about the plight of Hindus and other minorities in bangladesh.
-
SOkay, what exactly is your solution for those poor people?
Bring them here and people like yourself will whine because “refugees don’t deserve help from India”. Let them die and we can already see your response.
Do you propose invading them?
-
RWhat do you think India is ? Anyone can come, do as they please and leave ? Is that what you are proposing ? Where did I say that we should bring all refugees here ?
-
-
-
-
-
RIndia is not a dumping ground for illegals just because their parents came illegal and had a child here in India doesn’t make them indian
-
-
-
-
-
SBro got downvoted for being prejudiced, assuming her parents were not born here, and subscribing to the “Guilty unless proven innocent” principle.
-
-
-
SWhat a dumb logic. India is one of those nations that has indirect taxation, so every one pays taxes via GST.
If you’re so concerned about your tax money then you should be asking questions to the government and not punching down on poor people who are just trying to make ends meet.
PS. 16 lakhs is a pittance. Aukat do kaudi ki bhi nahi hai, attitude Ambani wala
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
SContact a lawyer and get ready to pay the bills. There’s no easy way to solve this without the involvement of a legal professional. I don’t know if you can find pro bono legal service in your city. Check with ngos if they can take the case.
As a citizen, you won’t be able to solve this yourself without legal help.
-
-
SAnd she’s still in jail. Reach out to an ngo or go public on Twitter. Someone needs to clear her case, and the police don’t seem to care.
One thing – doesn’t she have any relatives in India? Unless someone’s an orphan, she must be having someone in her family. Why don’t you try contacting them? If she was an orphan, then an orphanage would have her records.
Contacting them would be the best way. They can get further documents and also reach out to local political leaders in West Bengal to get support.
-
CShe doesn’t have any relatives in West Bengal, she only has her mother who lives here in Maharashtra and have Indian Citizenship
-
-
-
-
-
QGet the documents which prove she is born in India The easiest and fastest route as per me is to file a writ petition in high court under article 226/227 against the authorities i e the police department and the concerned department which ordered her detention as her constitution right to be free and get her released on bail immediately don’t give any money as bribe to anybody
-
-
LAFAIK just being born in india does not mean you get citizenship, one needs to have parents who are citizens as well.
-
-
SHow do you know that?
If they were Indians, they why would they arrest her, you have written a story without any proof
If she is an Indian, then you can reach out to different media outlets and share the story, muslim victimhood sells really well and there is no shortage of people who are ready to take up such cases.
-
SSir, can you just take your bigotry and go to the incel subs? This is not the sub or platform for you
-
-
-
-
GAre you really sure about all the facts she stated ? It’s just her claim that she’s Indian citizen when she actually might not be.
There are many illegal immigrants from Bangladesh in India who have fake documents like fake Aadhar cards, ration cards, pan cards etc. which they acquired after crossing the border
-
-
-
-
EWhat are those documents?
Most of the documents can be forged, apart from maybe passport. So unless she has that and you are 100% sure, stay out of it.
-
-
-
-
-
BBuddy 95% of the Bangladeshis being detained have valid Aadhars, Ration Cards and other documents. The West Bengal government has been providing all these to illegal immigrants for vote bank politics. So let the police do their job. If you’re very sure, then please lawyer up.
-
-
-
SI’m sorry, but documents can be easily forged. It’s best to follow proper law about these things and avoid paying bribes.
You’ll end up losing your money, time, and also she will get deported.
-
VThis. When op said she was born here, i doubt it unless that woman’s parents were working for op or ops parents when she was born. Police detained her and kept her despite bail. They even kept the kid.
The woman was staying with other Bangladeshis who were illegal immigrans . Usually people staying in another country illegally will huddle together and not keep an outsider in their homes for the fear of being outed. How did they decide to let her stay?
OP, tread with caution. You might get yourself in a mess you’re not aware of. If you know for yourself she was born here then sure help her. But if this is what she told you then please be careful about your next steps.
-
-
RIf she is not born before 1987, she’ll need to prove that her parents are Indian.
Not sure what the current process is. It is a bit easier for most Christians since our churches have records of births and deaths usually. I needed church documents of my parents to prove that they really belong to my caste. Based on that, the Tehsildar gave a nativity and caste certificate. Based on this caste certificate, my caste certificate in Maharashtra was issued.
It would be similar, I’d assume, to prove citizenship as well.
-
-
D95% of “legal experts” here don’t understand that if you ignore “ration card,” there’s NO WAY for a person to prove birth/stay in India other than maybe neighbour’s testimony if they’re uneducated.
And if you try to judge people from their “Bengaliness” , it’s impossible to differentiate because North Bengal / Border area s dialect is exactly same .
This is what you get with unnatural borders / partition.
Innocent and poor people languishing in jail.
While ultra rich get out after murder for 300 word essay .
What a disgrace of a nation we have become.
Future is utterly dark for this country.
-
LThis is heartbreaking and completely unjust. No one should be exploited, or separated from their rights because of corruption. If she has documents proving her Indian citizenship, she deserves immediate legal help. Please reach out to a human rights lawyer or a legal aid organization, they might be able to intervene. I really hope she and her child get justice soon.
-
