- This topic has 79 replies, 23 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 3 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
UThis is to notify all, There has been an incident at the front gate of my society Ghaziabad UP 201017 around 8:50pm 4 march 2025, where a car [DL 5CJ 2579]. A guest for flat has drove the car slowly over [Dog and her 5 puppies] which lives at construction site beside our society everyone must be familiar with the puppies as they are there from over past 3 months, few of our society mates feed them on regular basis hence nurturing and caring them in most humble and peak humanity manner.
This incident took place in front of my eyes and several other people including guards, Construction worker, contractor.
I will be attaching the incident video which took from the cctv of the main gate, this was the furthest view possible as cctv are not available ton the steel gate,
Incident is as follows-“Chameli, the mother of 5 puppies standing their and her 5 puppies including the one which already has a dislocated hind leg were drinking her milk and I was standing there and guarding the so called possibility of the incident which did took place,
A car swift dzire aim to enter the society took turn on the ram and successfully ignoring 2 cement rack in the way, and slowly steering straight to enter and there all dogs where standing, and I saw this and moved to signal the driver about them as I was trying to prevent such incident at that moment, and in front of my eyes only he drove very elegantly over the puppies, 4 puppies cam under the car and 1 puppy which is probably the most healthiest Among them came under the tyre.
I ran towards the car as the puppies starting whining and shouting, I punch the bonnet of the car twice to make him realize what he did with all the windows open, and hence his lethargic attitude he very softly and unbothoredly put it in reverse and moved and in the meantime the pup was under the tyre only.
His right arm was fully tore from his elbow, he ran away shouting inside to seek shelter,Now the conversations I Had with the whole family [man, his old mother, 2 young kid(boy and girl)]
Me- Bhai kya kara hai yeah pi rakhi hai kya
Him – “very unbothoredly” : Are kya Hua sadak p roz dasiyo marte h.
Me- Bhai toh kya hua maarega kya aise phir
Him- Akad mat Jayda
Me- Akad rha hu tu bahar nikap“Me asked one of my friend Arun advocate who was supposedly coming from his office, I told him to click the photograph of the vehicle which he took and I will be attaching, as I was not carrying my phone with me, I asked him to dail 112 and after trying twice the call didn’t go through”
Him -“Han bhai dikha nhi ucha h na”
“Question arises if ramp is that big the a group of whites dogs are not visible, when apparently he did saw the cement rack of same height”
Me- bhai aapki gaadi koi inti uchi nhi hai jo road hi na dikhe.
“Now there happens lot of argument where I was trying to make him realize what he have and seems like neither he nor his family including young kids which I am shocked to see, have no reaction towards the incident, weren’t even slightly ashamed of what they have done, and perhaps trying to make me realize that these dogs life doesn’t matter”
Me-“ab isko doctor k leke jana h mein apni scooty bula rha hu”
“To check his and his mother’s mentality I raised a question who will bear the financial amount for his proper treatment”
His mother- “main 500 rs de deti hu”
Me-“Mataji 500 mein koi thik nhi hota”
His mother-“ab koi doctor kitna hi bill band de”
Me- “mata mera koi rishtedaar nhi h doctor ki baad m hum paisa baatenge, jo lagega wo lagegar”
His daughter possibily- “bhaiya hum 100 kutte palate isme kya hai
Me-“didi aap 110 paalo par hamare in 5 ko toh mat maaro”“This arises a question In my mind which I think many of you will be thinking, that a street dog life value is just 500rs for them apparently that’s lesser than the farmhouse Dominos pizza people eating these days”
“Strange to see no empathy, no shame for doing such heinous act”
Me- “aap log jaaiye apna time enjoy kariye milne aaye h mein Deka lunga. Ab isko kaise thik karna hai”
“Absurd thing is family genuinely took off from the main gate itself as I suppose whom they meant to pick from society did came to the main gate 1 woman and 1 girl. And in blink of eye they were gone”
“Vet examined him and bandage his leg to stop the bleeding as the bone is properly visible from a 5 inch wound on a 3 months puppy, he will do plaster or other procedure tomorrow morning”
“I request you al to have empathy against those puppies this is a hard time now, I don’t have the facility to foster 5 puppies, but please try your best to not make their life more hard on street as well”
“Is this the kind of people we are surrounded with on daily basis, yes it seems, we have bring this out and do think of this incident fro sometime in alone, especially your kids as they are young I hope you guys are giving your best to make them a good person, do tell them to love the unspeakables they just want love nothing else from you, let it be dogs, cows, horses. No need to teach them up front are don’t go near it will bite, seengh mara degi.”
Only we the power to change the thinking and that will be the right thing to do.
Hence loyalty cannot be bought it can only be earned.Have a goodnight everyone.
-
UPeople in the comment section supporting the family are ridiculous!!!
To those stupid people:
Humans kill other humans/animals far more than dogs kill humans. When will you realize that we are the worst? The crime rates we see are not committed by animals. It’s done by evil humans with no humanity. Unfortunately, I don’t think they will suffer any dire consequences through law. But I hope that family or anyone with no empathy experiences the same treatment they give to animals.
P.s. You are a good person, OP!
-
-
UNot supporting the family but stray dogs should be eradicated it’s not worth taking the risk of getting their bites and be in life or death situation,People shouting “That Maybe You Shouldn’t Scare Them” Where you a dog in your last life cuz sure as hell y’all talking from sm great experience if other countries can curb the issue why can’t we take initiative? It’s mind boggling how sm dog lovers would rather kill a human over a dog
-
USo your solution to animal control is just running them over? That’s not control, it’s cruelty. Strays need shelter and neutering, not a hit-and-run policy. There’s a big difference between managing the issue and just being inhumane and reckless.
>It’s mind boggling how sm dog lovers would rather kill a human over a dog
Yeah, I would’ve replied the same way if it was a cat or a chicken. The post was about a man and his family running over dogs and not having empathy. It’s human error. Period.
-
MRabies vaccination is given free of cost at government hospitals. The municipalities also give free vaccination to stray dogs if someone alerts the municipal authorities of stray population and free neuter drives are also held where people register to neuter stray dogs nearby. But most people would rather poison and kill these innocents than take effort for what you want to achieve
-
-
-
LStreet dogs are huge menace in india. Needs to be culled. Why didn’t you give shelter to this dog family since 3 months ?
-
UThey have proper space for eat and sleep but they do wander around. Today i will be giving them to proper shelter i have been in touch with them
-
CWhile I have dogs. There are both sides of arguments about street dogs and truly empathise with the situation. Street dogs have become a menace and attacked a kid near my house. People who care for street dogs don’t pick up and clean their shit as well and this has caused a big issue in our street. When I tell people who care to call up shelters or donate to create a shelter and clean up after the dogs , they look at me all weird.I clean up after my dog and have poop bags.
-
-
UIndia has an overpopulation problem. Maybe we should start running men over, since they tend to harass women and don’t know how to behave.
See how retarded you sound?
-
-
-
LThat’s tbe norm everywhere else in tbe world. Street dogs spread diseases like rabies and make roads and street extremely unsafe for children. India is the only country where street dogs are not culled. Even in this example, tbe OP knew the dog for over 3 months and still didn’t bother to shelter it or provide rescue home- but when it died due to unfortunate incident (how is he sure it was purposefully run over ? Who would risk destruction to car running over animals? ) , suddenly OP becomes animal lover and activist. Total hypocrisy
-
UThey all care so badly about dogs but cant even let them inside their own houses,these dogs will cause a huge menace to people on the street,India will be the only country where mfs care for stray dogs and not the humans who get bitten or what not and the audacity of op being self righteous as if he sheltered those dogs
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
EI don’t understand why people are so much bothered by street dogs, I mean if you have so much empathy take them home, make them your pet, take care of them.
What the car guy did was wrong but why the dogs are there in the first place you or your society management could’ve taken care of those when you know they are at risk.
People want others to take care of those things nobody wants to take responsibility but when something happens to street dogs all of you people shout like hell. Dogs bite someone – no issue, no responsibility…… Dogs make the society hell by fecal matter here n there, no issue, no responsibility…… something happens then you guys come and make arguments.
-
UBrother i take full responsibility they live on my adjacent construction site they have all amenities they have peacfull life but they do roam outside as of curiosity and the reason i can not take them i already hve a dog at and in my flat there is no space for add on
-
PDon’t explain him anything. We (4-5 families here) take care of stray dogs while the rest of the society shoos them away or insults the dogs. But still somehow we are the culprits bcz they believe we are sheltering them. Such people don’t understand that if you’ll feed and love a dog, they will never bite you back.
-
-
ERoam around out of curiosity….. Brother that’s called poop around ……. Don’t be all saint. Good for you to have a dog and i hope you do the right thing (unlike majority of the pet owners ).
-
-
EThat’s why I said I hope you do the right thing. I hope every pet owner do that (but they don’t ….. especially people from gzb/UP just walk around with their pet and boom baam (😂) on public area. I’ve seen people making their pet release around my home and I’ve instantly called out on them….but the audacity of those pet owners ….godd i hate em all )
-
-
E1000 gaj godd damm …. And somehow still dont have a place for street dogs haan …..good going brother …..keep calling police and fight about what happened….. I hope you initiate taking care of those. As of my eye ….if you (and all those people who feed stray dogs) actually care then give them shelter and proper arrangements rather than making these posts. It’s not like he went especially out of his way to do what he did.
-
UThey were born in that construction site only 3.5 months those people are so good including worker we combined made pups stays as safe as possible and there medicine and feeding on time every one is trying there best, i am also keeping on other pup of same litter who had hip dislocated to car bang.
Hence i am trying my best to take care of them
-
-
-
-
-
UAnd just for refernece their mother never harmed she always lived there friends with my dog as well i have know her from very long.
Thanks for your pov
But when a dog bite someone there is all drama and fine and when a person then no action? So thanks for ur views probably think u might be on the other side of the coin and all of us-
ESure please action on the one who did wrong if you’re the owner of the pet. Other side of what coin? I’m not doing any harm to any street dogs but I’m not playing the game of being on both side like you people do ….. I’ve seen personally how people (most) who have pets handle their pets. It’s all hell no responsibility for their actions (I’ve seen so much poop coz the owners don’t want to pick it up and just make the society filthy coz they think it’s the responsibility of cleaners to clean.
I live in blore and in my society people do pick up and walk around with pets on leash. And I’m from gaziabad so don’t tell me i already know what’s the state of gzb …… Pet Owners are dumb af.
-
UI trained my dog for pee and poop inside bathroom he always does it in home and then leave for stressfree walks.
If you live here do meet me in person and i will show you the sophistication of pet owners in my circle.-
EI’m very happy for you. I hope other people learn from you and you also tell the stupid dumb pet owners who don’t follow these things.
-
UI try my best, because washroom habit is great as pet don’t need to control pee for too long and hence saving kidneys in long run
-
EPee is fine ……I don’t have issue with it …… Technically it’s good only for trees n plants …… I hate number 2 …..hate it …..hate it to my core
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
UActually if a dog bites there are various organisations supporting the dogs and advocating animals rights,meanwhile incidents such as the above are vary rare,street dogs cause more harm to people than vice versa as only one of them has any type of intellectual capabilities.
The irony is nobody cares about sterilising them and this in return will haunt the country in future in terms of tourism and public safety
-
-
-
Ehttps://www.reddit.com/r/LegalAdviceIndia/s/hab48sfs2r
There you go …..see this is more often than what happened with op
-
-
UThe dogs didn’t deserve what happened to them especially if it was done intentionally (which I doubt because why would someone intentionally run over dogs but anyways) . Not related to this specific incident but people like you are the real nuisance for the society. Agar Kutto se itna pyaar Hai to Ghar pr paalo na. Tmlog ko bs koi responsibility nhi chahiye aur Kutto se pyaar krne ka dhong krte ho. We see so so many cases Ki Kaise in street dogs jinko tum Jaise log “khule me paalte ho” , wo chote bacho ko kaat lete Hain . Kayi Baar bacho Ki Jaan v chali jaati Hai and it’s not even that rare. Just search Google and you’ll find numerous such cases. Bs Shaam ko office se aake EK packet biscuit khila dena kutte paalna nhi hota. Call animal helpline aur in Kutto ko hatwao society se
-
UBhai mere ghar pe already hai and flat chote hone ki wajah se ek aur nhi la skta isiliye unka pura section uss site pee poop section and sleeping and bed everything
And please have your fucking pov with yourself asshole hypocrite here is u-
UAgar dusro ka pov nhi Sunna to internet pe post kyu krta Hai bkl.
Agar apna Ghar chota Hai to un Kutto ko Kisi shelter me ya fr Ngo me pahuchane ka intezam kr na. Society pr mt thop. You’re just proving my point Ki Apne koi responsibility nhi Lena Hai BS dusro ka moral policing krna haiAgar sach me care krta hota to sirf sympathy dikhane ke bajaye inke lite proper arrangement krta . Bas rant krne se nhi hota, zimmedari uthani pdti hai
-
-
-
MThey are protected by the right to life without harm by the constitution of India. You have a problem with this, leave the country. Aaj isne kutte ko mara hai kal insaan ko marega as most psychopaths start experimenting with animal cruelty before taking human lives. People cannot be seriously talking about how feeding dogs is a nuisance when it’s obvious that healthy and fed dogs are less likely to be aggressive. They have as much right to live as you and anyone else. I wish the Indian curriculum taught ethics and morality to citizens.
-
UThe constitution also protects the right to safety for human beings, including children who are often the victims of stray dog attacks. If you care so much about these dogs, why not take full responsibility for them instead of leaving them on the streets where they can be a danger to others? Aaj ek kutta ne bachhe ko kaat liya toh kal kya hoga? Why should society suffer just because a few people want to “care” for animals without any real responsibility?
Also, comparing this to psychopathy is a stretch. There’s a big difference between someone intentionally torturing animals for pleasure and a driver who may not have even seen the dogs. If feeding dogs truly made them peaceful, we wouldn’t have countless cases of aggressive stray dog attacks. If you love them so much, take them home. Stop forcing them on everyone else.
-
MThe Constitution of India protects their rights. You are in no position to tell anyone what to do with strays.
Rabid dogs are put down.
Most dogs can be vaccinated and neutered to reduce their population. If you’re not willing to take additional efforts to achieve a result you actually want, then stop telling people what they should and shouldn’t do.
Strays in our society are vaccinated and neutered. I am doing my part to reduce this nuisance. You should do yours.
-
-
-
UIt’s true that there are incidents like this but downright blaming people who care about dogs is just wrong.
Agr aap ye bol rhe ho ki dogs bite people what about other way around let me know how many times you have taken dogs for medical attention or file FIR on people when they have been run over or beaten to death.You have the right to raise voice against overpopulation of stray dogs but you can only do so if you are also raising voicing against injustice done to them.
I do agree there should be sterilisation drive done at every society to curb this problem and reduce overpopulation-
UI get your point, and I agree that animal cruelty is wrong and should be condemned. But at the same time, it’s also unfair to dismiss people’s concerns about stray dog attacks. Just like dogs deserve protection from cruelty, humans especially kids snd elderly peopledeserve safety from aggressive strays.
You’re asking how many times someone has helped an injured dog, but the same question can be asked in reverse , how many times have dog feeders taken responsibility when a stray bites someone? The reality is, many just feed them but don’t ensure sterilization, vaccination, or proper care. If you truly care about dogs, the focus should not be just defendong them blindly
people have the right to feel concerned about their safety too. Compassion should go both ways : for animals and for humans.
-
UI agree and I have written in a different comment that both are different problems and need different preventive measures.
Yes I do agree that the dogs that I feed is my responsibility that it does not attack a person BUT it is only my responsibility if the attack was unprovoked.if the attack was provoked by the other person every living being has right to defend itself.
Let’s not generalise that feeding dogs are bad but let’s encourage a behaviour where it is responsibility for everyone in the society to sterilize and rehabilitate them where these type of attacks are common. -
-
-
-
UYour balanced and logical argument is being downvoted. God bless such ppl and save our country from such hypocritical animal lovers.
These ppl only indulge in virtue signaling but conveniently ignore these same animals when it comes taking actual action like adopting them and bringing them home.
-
UAs I said in different comment,I don’t understand the need for this argument here.OP is reporting a crime which is illegal and against the law according to the constitution of India.What is the need for bringing the argument that stray dogs are menace and overpopulated.
We can have a discussion on a different thread regarding this problem but what is it relevancy here.
You won’t start saying crimes committed by humanity and overpopulation if a human would have come under the car because it is irrelevant and does not bring any solution to the original problem.
He deserves to be downvoted because he brought a baseless argument to a problem which is not at all relevant.If you want to discuss on the overpopulation and dog attacking humans create a different thread and invite me.-
UHow is the problem he stated not relevant? Have you never seen a stray dog sitting right in the middle of the road refusing to move even after honking?
This is a legal advise sub, and looking at the post it feels like a sob-story and guilt offloading by the OP as he was unable to prevent the accident even after being aware of the likelihood of it happening due to the location at which the mother dog was standing.
The car was entering the premises and the driver had entire family including kids in it. This definitely means two things, firstly that the driver wasn’t intoxicated, and secondly, he wasn’t speeding.
OP’s post insinuated that the car was deliberately driven over the stray animal and its pups, but his narrative of the incident points at something else.
Any sensible person would have lifelong trauma if he was driving that car. And i hold these irresponsible, virtue signaling self proclaimed “animal lovers” for this suffering of both the animal and the humans.
If these animal lovers feel so deeply for the animals walk the talk and adopt all the strays that you come across.
Give them shelter and food, spend the money required for their maintenance. But no…..they’d buy 10 Rupees biscuit, pat the dog, and rant when they meet with an accident on the streets, hilarious maturity levels lol
-
-
-
-
-
UWhat kind of a comment section is this???? Yes, street dogs have become a problem in India but how and why are people justifying the actions of the man who drove over 5 puppies and their mother??? Is killing puppies and dogs and maybe even other pests with such brutality the solution to dogs population problem??? People have become desensitized to crimes like these.
Also the people who think the man didn’t do it intentionally, you’re telling me that the man couldn’t see 5 PUPPIES AND A DOG on the road?????
Also thank you op for taking initiative regarding this matter.
-
UThanks dude its been a crazy incident unable to see even all white dogs. In area sizing where 2 full truck can park adjacent.
-
UMan this was literally hundred percent intentional. It’s so shitty to hear someone would go out of their way to literally murder innocent lives.
-
-
-
-
UAll those who are saying dogs are menace and their population should be reduced
I request you to not to stay silent when these type of incidents occur also.
Leaving any living being to die on the road is downright evil and not morally justifiable.
Just sitting behind a screen and not taking any responsibility is hypocrisy.
Also those who are saying killing is justifiable for any living being need to go back to the school for their moral science classes.
These two issues are totally different and need different preventive measures. -
-
-
-
ZI feel sorry for the kids in the car. This karma will be very heavy to bear. When will ppl understand that karma doesn’t spare anyone or anything.
-
-
-
-
-
-
UPeople bringing the argument that dog overpopulation is a problem, there is certainly something wrong with your logical thinking abilities.You cannot justify this with another argument.
Let’s say if there would have been a child run over by a car,would you have reacted in the same way.The person who did this can run over a child also.
You guys need to understand that the people here don’t know how to drive and are not at all care about the consequences of their actions for which they need to be punished.
If a person can run over a dog he can run over a child also.
You guys should give some good advices to OP and not argue.Please think again whether you are helping OP bring justice to the crime committed or subdue his efforts by bringing in baseless argument not relevant to the thread.-
UThanks i will have done same it was the kid. Thanks for the support just trying my best at this my major priority is his well being and other 4 pups and their mothers.
Rn not thinking anything else i left everything to god -
-
-
AWoah!!! I hope if we were in the same city I could have tried something and make those bastards really pay…
-
UNo worries people like this happens to in every corner of this world. I just know that god is watching them all and karma will comeback
-
AI know yaar it makes my blood boil… just today I got a kitten home.. he was in the middle of footpath and I was keeping him in side, he would return there.. and few people even stepped on him!! People think they’re above every other creature deserve to show their place!!
-
-
-
-
-
-
MCan’t believe people are deliberately killing innocent animals & then justifying it. op you did right !! Please complain to police. People lack empathy !
-
-
