- This topic has 7 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 2 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
HHi everyone,
I’m looking for some legal advice regarding a prolonged issue concerning my late father, who was a central government employee.
He passed away in December 2024. At the time, there was an old CBI case pending against him (related to service matters from over a decade ago). The internal departmental proceedings were finalized in 2015, but the criminal case remains pending before a Special CBI Court.
As per **Section 394 of the CrPC**, criminal proceedings abate upon the death of the accused(Info from ChatGPT). We formally **notified the court in January 2025 through our legal counsel**, but despite that, the case is still shown as active, and nothing has been officially abated.(Forensic report submitted by CBI on 10th April 2025, next hearing is on 29th April 2025)
This has resulted in a complete freeze of his pensionary benefits including pension, gratuity, and leave encashment, which should be released to the family. To add to it, there’s also an unresolved issue regarding the regularization of his suspension period, which further delays the final settlement.
As far as I know, under **Rule 35 and Rule 9(6) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021**, no penalty can be imposed after the death of a government servant, and pensionary benefits cannot be withheld in such a case unless misconduct was proven during their lifetime. (Info from ChatGPT)
We have submitted:
* His death certificate was sent to my father’s office and the Court.
* Pension papers, including a provisional pension application due to a delay, but they are not forwarding the documents.… but still, there’s been no progress. The family is under emotional and financial stress because of this.
What are our options now?
I have written an application to my father’s office, but not sure whether the rules mentioned in the application are true. I am worried that the mentioned rules might backfire on us, due to complex provisions in the same section. (yet to submit, need help)
My Lawyer is asking for heavy fees, and I will pay the remaining dues next month. Till then, I need my father’s office to take action.
Has anyone dealt with such a case before? Any help, advice, or pointers would really mean a lot.
Thanks in advance.
-
QHow do you even find a trustworthy lawyer in such cases? Lawyers ask for large upfront money in most cases and there is no system of taking anyone to account for their promises in India.. cases may drag on forever and you would be powerless to do anything. There is no system of records that lets you choose a lawyer based on track records…
-
-
-
-
BNAL-
1. **Criminal Case and Section 394 of CrPC**: You’re correct that according to **Section 394 of the CrPC**, criminal proceedings **abate** upon the death of the accused. This should mean that the case is technically over, and your father’s estate (including pension) should not be held up by an ongoing criminal case. However, the CBI Court has not officially confirmed this, and they’ve continued to keep the case as “active.” This is either incompetence or bureaucracy trying to find an excuse to avoid action.
2. **Pension Rules and Withholding Benefits**: The **CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021**, you mentioned are pretty clear that after the death of a government employee, benefits cannot be withheld unless misconduct is proven during their lifetime. If there was no proven misconduct, the pension should be released. But the issue here is the system refusing to acknowledge the law. Your father’s office is holding up the benefits, probably because they are waiting for the court to officially close the case. This is where you need to make some noise.
3. **Your Next Steps**:
– **Keep Pushing the Pension Office**: You’ve already sent the death certificate and pension papers, but that’s just the first step. The pension office is likely hoping you’ll give up and move on. **Send a follow-up letter** (preferably through registered post or email) pointing out that, according to the rules, the pension cannot be withheld because your father’s misconduct was never proven. Quote **Rule 35 and Rule 9(6)** clearly. It’s important to **reference** these rules and ask them to expedite the release of the pension as your father’s death and the case’s abatement under Section 394 should make this straightforward.
– **Escalate**: If the local office is not responding, take it **up the chain**. Go higher to the **Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions** or the relevant central government authority. They can push the local office to act faster. **File an RTI** (Right to Information) request asking why the pension is still being held up and what steps they are taking to release it.
– **Court Notification**: Since the court has not abated the case despite the death notice, you can **send a reminder** through your lawyer or directly (if you can) to the CBI court. Clearly state that **as per Section 394 of the CrPC**, criminal proceedings should have been terminated, and the case should be considered closed. You can even request the **court to issue an official order** to the department for the pension to be released. Sometimes, a reminder from the court can get things moving faster.
– **Lawyer’s Fees**: I get that the lawyer’s fees are high, but **if you can, try to get them to help you draft a letter to your father’s office**. Government offices tend to take things seriously when they’re communicated through an official legal channel. While your lawyer may charge a lot, this **could be an investment** in speeding up the process. If you’re stuck for funds, ask your lawyer if they can offer a **payment plan** or reduce the amount for handling the paperwork.4. **Financial Stress**: This is an obvious mess, and the system is designed to break your spirit. But don’t give up. You’ve done the right thing by following up, so keep at it. The more you follow up with **official channels** and **remind them of the rules**, the harder it will be for them to ignore you.
You have the rules on your side, and the government’s refusal to release your father’s benefits is **illegal** under those rules. Keep pushing them with **official letters**, **RTI requests**, and **reminders to the court**. You’ve done the groundwork, now it’s time to escalate until they can’t avoid you. The more noise you make, the quicker this will get resolved.
-
-
