- This topic has 3 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 4 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
UHi everyone,
A friend of mine who works in a government department in India recently received a charge sheet for misconduct because he sent an email to a higher authority without following the proper channel. He is now facing possible disciplinary action, and I wanted to get some legal perspectives on whether he has a strong defense, given the inconsistent enforcement of this rule.
Timeline of Events:
14-06-2024 & 15-06-2024 – He sent an email and a written letter to the Directorate. No action was taken, and he was not warned or questioned.
16-07-2024 – He sent another email to a Circle-level authority. This time, he was suddenly questioned for misconduct.
18-07-2024 – His Immediate Authority took his statement, where he admitted he was unaware of the rule and assured compliance in the future.
13-02-2025 – Despite his assurance, his Divisional Head issued a charge sheet, stating that his explanation was not acceptable.
Key Points of His Defense:
1. Inconsistent Enforcement – If directly emailing higher authorities was a serious violation, why wasn’t he questioned for his June 2024 emails? The rule was not actively enforced, leading to confusion.
2. No Intentional Misconduct – Since there was no previous warning, he genuinely believed direct emails were allowed.
3. Immediate Compliance – As soon as he was informed in July 2024, he followed the correct process and has not repeated the mistake.
Potential Risks:
The department might club all his communications together and argue that this was a pattern of misconduct, potentially leading to a severe penalty (suspension, pay cut, etc.).
Questions:
1. Does the lack of action on his June 2024 emails help his case?
2. Can he argue that this is selective enforcement, making the charge sheet unfair?
3. What’s the best way for him to phrase his response to ensure the least severe penalty?
Would appreciate any legal insights or similar experiences. Thanks in advance!
-
SYour friend’s department likely has a CVC – create an enquiry with them. The more documentation the better.
-
UThank you .. But The department issued charge sheet to him he need to answer in writing to them again before 10 days
-
-
-
