- This topic has 24 replies, 18 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 2 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
EI need some legal advice regarding a property matter in India.
My grandfather bought a house with his own money (self-acquired property). He has 4 children: 3 sons (including my father) and 1 daughter.
My father and one uncle passed away a few years ago.
For the past 20 years, my grandfather has lived with us (me and my family), and we’ve taken care of him, even after my father passed away.
A few years ago, my grandfather executed a gift deed and transferred the entire house to me.
Now, my cousin (uncle’s son) and one surviving uncle are threatening to file a complaint or send legal notices claiming their share.
My grandfather is currently staying at that uncle’s house and is suffering from Alzheimer’s.
Both my uncles already own separate houses. We don’t have any other property except this one.
I want to know:
-Can they legally challenge the gift deed?
-Is there any risk of the property being divided among all heirs?
-What steps should I take to protect myself?
Thanks in advance for your guidance.
-
SIs the gift deed registered?
Since your grandpa is now suffering from alzheimer’s, did you take a doctor’s report before executing and registering the gift deed?
If answers to both these questions are yes, then nothing to worry about.
-
-
-
-
GGift deed once executed cannot be revoked.
Once the donor gifts any property and the donee accepts it, it gets finalised and cannot be challenged.But if they take any ground, that your grandfather is suffering from mental ill condition at the time of execution of deed and you influenced him to write in your favour, then scene may become a bit tricky..
Nothing to worry about..
But they may drag you into unnecessary litigation resulting in unwanted litigation expenses and time loss.
-
EThank you for your guidance. In the deed it is clearly mentioned by my grandpa that “I hereby willingly and knowingly transfer ownership to you without any pressure, temptation, compensation, or conditions, and in full mental and emotional clarity, in the presence of witnesses.”
-
-
-
-
HEverything can be challenged. However, whether the challenge succeeds is an entirely different question.
A registered gift deed is generally regarded as a secure mode of property transfer, and there are limited grounds on which it can be successfully contested in court. However, that does not prevent your uncle from filing case challenging the gift deed.
As a precaution for future, ensure that your uncle does not trick your grandfather into signing or executing any other documents that could later be used to raise doubts about the validity of the gift deed.
-
-
-
MMy grand dad too was having alzhemier during his last stage although he prepared the will for all his assets which was registered by lawyer in my dad’s name when he was fit and fine. Though thr was no registery done for the property it was just the hand written will which i guess was already submitted to court and lawyer.
But after his demise my all other uncles and cousins created the chaos for the property and his all other financial assets stating that we would have got that will forcefully by him when was suffering and all other obligations which really made me feel sad and angry since my parents and took care of him all his lifetime also he was too attached to my parents out of everyone of them. When he was bed ridden no one even come to visit and check on him ☹️.So just to get off from all the stress my parents were not ready to sale my garndfather’s property and assets so they did sold there own two properties and payed them all the amm in cash and then got the registery done of my GrandDad’s property on there name for which we had to pay approx 1 percent of the total property value to govt.
all this still make me angry and whenever i meet them i feel like beating the shit out of them.
-
-
-
-
-
BYou need strong evidence that your grandfather gifted it when he was in his right mind and not after being diagnosed with Alzheimer’s (or early stages when he still had mental clarity). In your case most of the legal ramifications would be based on this – whether your grandfather gifted the house to you WHEN he was in right mind and not under duress or mental confusion from the disease. If that can be proved, as long as the property is his hard earned and not inheritance, he can choose to give it to anyone he likes.
-
-
-
-
-
P– anyone can sue anyone, it’s a free country. But it doesn’t mean they’ll win the case.
– if your gift deed is registered, it’s solid. And you need to get evidence that he was mentally fit while handing it to you and get the proof that he’s mentally unfit now – so that if in case your uncle gets something signed now, that’s void.
– in many such cases, people just sell off the property because you can’t sell the property until the case goes on. Selling it before the court trial starts can be considered suspicious, but if you’ve all the documents, let the case go on for years, atleast you’ll have the money out off that property.
-
