Minor Accident – Other Driver Threatening FIR, Need Advice

Community Forums Legal Advice India Minor Accident – Other Driver Threatening FIR, Need Advice

Viewing 11 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #11346 Reply
      Superswara5812
      Participant
        S
        Superswara5812
        PARTICIPANT
        April 20, 2025 at 4:18 pm
        Yesterday, I was in my Baleno being driven by my driver, waiting at a signal. We had to take a right turn. As soon as the signal turned green for a right turn, my driver gave the indicator and made the turn. Meanwhile, a Honda Amaze (driven by a young guy) was right behind us on the right side, also trying to take the turn. That car hit ours on the right side, and both vehicles ended up with minor scratches. I was with my family, and since the damage was minimal, neither of us stopped.

        Today, however, I received a call from the Honda Amaze owner. He tried to threaten me, saying he had my contact details and address and had obtained CCTV footage from the police. He wanted me to go come to a specific police station and see the footage. He stated that in footage it is visible that my car came from behind and suddenly turned right — which isn’t what actually happened. He told me it would be better if I paid for the repairs, or he would file an FIR.

        I initially asked him to send the footage via WhatsApp, but he insisted I come in person. I didn’t give in to the pressure and told him I believed the fault was his, not mine. I also told him he was free to file an FIR if he wanted.

        I think he was trying to bluff.

        But also confused and concerned:

        1. How did he get my name and complete mobile number? (Especially since the RTO is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.)

        2. If he does file an FIR, what is the likely course of action? Should I be worried?

      • #11357 Reply
        Alphabro1965
        Participant
          A
          Alphabro1965
          PARTICIPANT
          April 20, 2025 at 4:35 pm
          Unless I misunderstood, the other guy was in the right lane and your driver was in the left/centre It seems to me your driver turned right without checking the ORVM. He might have signalled but that doesn’t entitle him to change lanes without checking whether there was traffic behind.

          Or did I misunderstand ?

          • #11364 Reply
            Rapidshreya945
            Participant
              R
              Rapidshreya945
              PARTICIPANT
              April 20, 2025 at 4:43 pm
              >As soon as the signal turned green for a right turn, my driver gave the indicator

              Dude really said “I turn now, good luck everybody else”

            • #11363 Reply
              Superswara5812
              Participant
                S
                Superswara5812
                OP
                April 20, 2025 at 4:49 pm
                It was a single lane road, my car was in front left side to other car.

                • #11367 Reply
                  Alphabro1965
                  Participant
                    A
                    Alphabro1965
                    PARTICIPANT
                    April 20, 2025 at 5:04 pm
                    Sorry, it is not clear. If there was only one lane, how could your car have been to the left of the other car ? Generally in these kinds of accidents, the person who is on the left will be considered responsible because there would be less of a blind spot on the driver side than the passenger side and also because the traffic on the left should be moving slower.

              • #11356 Reply
                Superswara5812
                Participant
                  S
                  Superswara5812
                  OP
                  April 20, 2025 at 4:39 pm
                  There was no lane but a single road.

                • #11355 Reply
                  Mightykomal1002
                  Participant
                    M
                    Mightykomal1002
                    PARTICIPANT
                    April 20, 2025 at 6:48 pm
                    Looks like OP is at fault and still argues with full confidence. You cannot do a random right turn from the extreme left of the road. Accept your mistake and compensate him.

                  • #11354 Reply
                    Mightybear961
                    Participant
                      M
                      Mightybear961
                      PARTICIPANT
                      April 20, 2025 at 7:20 pm
                      In India slapping case in an accident where their is minor damage to both party does not make sense.

                      I am not saying who is wrong or right it does not matter but doing a case like this will be wastage of time for both and moreover biggest waste of time to the other guy who does FIR.

                      As Insurance company in India will fight with someone who claim damages from them as if he files for FIR Insurance company will be on the hook to fight that case. Company will fight for even a single paise (not rupee but PAISA) so if he wants to do FIR it is his problem just Inform your insurance company and ask them what you need to do. Its there daily work to go for court one extra case won’t harm them.

                      This thing opposite party knows so they will call you to police station to put pressure on you.just tell them that you have informed your insurance company and if they want to file FIR their is nothing to talk further.

                      • #11362 Reply
                        Alphabro1965
                        Participant
                          A
                          Alphabro1965
                          PARTICIPANT
                          April 21, 2025 at 2:38 am
                          The OP did not stop after the accident. The opposite party can put criminal sections on the OP, including hit and run. That will have to be faced by OP, not the insurance company.

                          • #11366 Reply
                            Mightybear961
                            Participant
                              M
                              Mightybear961
                              PARTICIPANT
                              April 22, 2025 at 12:49 am
                              As I said if he opp party wants money from op he can give settle.
                              If op refuses to do the same they will file charges and matter will go to courts and believe me I know this even if opp party has appetite for legal battle in this kind of situations their is no win for anyone both will loose time and legal fee will be far greater then the cost of repairs even in court op lose their will not any greater financial loss to the op other then legal fee as if opp party wants money they need to claim money from Insurance company and in India these company will fight you on every penny and till the end they will go to higher courts just exhaust you no matter the time for them.

                              • #11368 Reply
                                Alphabro1965
                                Participant
                                  A
                                  Alphabro1965
                                  PARTICIPANT
                                  April 22, 2025 at 1:35 am
                                  I am talking about the criminal sections. In a criminal case, the OP will be a defendant and the State will be the prosecutor. The insurance company will not be involved directly. The other guy is just a complainant and witness. He doesn’t have to pay the public prosecutor for a criminal case.

                          • #11353 Reply
                            Luckypunit4818
                            Participant
                              L
                              Luckypunit4818
                              PARTICIPANT
                              April 21, 2025 at 12:44 am
                              If he has zero-depreciation (zero-dep) coverage, he only needs to pay ₹1,000 for a claim. The same applies to comprehensive insurance—since it’s minor scratches, denting, and painting are fully covered under the comprehensive policy.

                              I’m not sure why an FIR is required unless it’s a major accident.

                              • #11361 Reply
                                Alphabro1965
                                Participant
                                  A
                                  Alphabro1965
                                  PARTICIPANT
                                  April 21, 2025 at 2:40 am
                                  Maybe the other guy is convinced the OP was at fault and he doesn’t want to lose his No Claim Bonus when he is convinced it was the other person’s fault.

                              • #11352 Reply
                                Coolking6164
                                Participant
                                  C
                                  Coolking6164
                                  PARTICIPANT
                                  April 21, 2025 at 1:04 am
                                  I’m still curious how the other driver managed to get all op details and that too on weekend holiday.

                                  • #11360 Reply
                                    Superswara5812
                                    Participant
                                      S
                                      Superswara5812
                                      OP
                                      April 21, 2025 at 12:25 pm
                                      That is what bothers me.

                                  • #11351 Reply
                                    Expertninja6581
                                    Participant
                                      E
                                      Expertninja6581
                                      PARTICIPANT
                                      April 21, 2025 at 6:09 am
                                      > Since the damage was minimal, neither of us stopped

                                      Are you sure it wasn’t just you guys who didn’t stop? Maybe the other guy did stop and wanted to assess the damage, but you just fled?

                                      • #11359 Reply
                                        Superswara5812
                                        Participant
                                          S
                                          Superswara5812
                                          OP
                                          April 21, 2025 at 12:24 pm
                                          I showed down a bit, He crossed me and didn’t stop.

                                      • #11350 Reply
                                        Rapidrider2250
                                        Participant
                                          R
                                          Rapidrider2250
                                          PARTICIPANT
                                          April 21, 2025 at 10:36 am
                                          What is this raod side gareebi? Both of you have third party and owner damage insurance, what`s the need for all this nautanki.? Lets assume this, your Car C and A is the opponent. As per your description this is what the situation was on the road |C|A|| You cannot turn right before A does. It is your fault, so initiate a third party claim, that is what you have insurance for.

                                        • #11349 Reply
                                          Nileshfox961
                                          Participant
                                            N
                                            Nileshfox961
                                            PARTICIPANT
                                            April 21, 2025 at 2:22 pm
                                            given the current scenario its difficult to make out who is on the wrong end. do you remember his face? or vehicle details of his?
                                            since he is mentioning you to come to specific police station, it kinda raises red flags.
                                            in my opinion he is trying to extort money?
                                            1. he could’ve stopped his vehicle there to have talk with you and discuss the issue.
                                            my strong advice unless you receive a complaint copy or fir copy don’t budge.

                                            • #11358 Reply
                                              Superswara5812
                                              Participant
                                                S
                                                Superswara5812
                                                OP
                                                April 21, 2025 at 3:11 pm
                                                I had slowed my car just to assess the damage, but dude went right pass me. If he wanted he surely could have stopped me easily.

                                                • #11365 Reply
                                                  Nileshfox961
                                                  Participant
                                                    N
                                                    Nileshfox961
                                                    PARTICIPANT
                                                    April 21, 2025 at 3:13 pm
                                                    I am sure these things will be in “CCTV FOOTAGE” he accessed from police station. just talk to any advocate if you know any one in your circle if you are so stressed out about the situation.

                                                    good day 🙂

                                              • #11348 Reply
                                                Viplavfalcon546
                                                Participant
                                                  V
                                                  Viplavfalcon546
                                                  PARTICIPANT
                                                  April 21, 2025 at 4:26 pm
                                                  Dude i think you are clearly at fault. Your driver did not give two hoots after just giving the indicator and trued to turn fast not caring the speed to the vehicle at the right side.

                                                • #11347 Reply
                                                  Coolknight1377
                                                  Participant
                                                    C
                                                    Coolknight1377
                                                    PARTICIPANT
                                                    April 23, 2025 at 11:29 pm
                                                    If there was a car on your right then you are in the wrong lane for a right turn. At the very least you could have taken a wider right turn leaving space for the car on your right.

                                                    Too many morons on the road these days. Just pay up for the damage you have caused.

                                                Viewing 11 reply threads
                                                Reply To: Reply #11361 in Minor Accident – Other Driver Threatening FIR, Need Advice
                                                Your information:




                                                Cancel