- This topic has 7 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 2 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
II’m a 26-year-old NRI and I’m going through a difficult situation that I’d really appreciate some guidance on. The story is a bit long and complicated, but please bear with me—I’ve been very anxious, and reading similar cases online has made me even more concerned.
**Background:** I visited India in October 2024. While I was there, a girl I had previously matched with on a matrimonial app (Shaadi) finally accepted my request. We met in person, and I was very transparent during our conversations about what I was seeking in a partner: emotional connection, spiritual alignment, and even physical intimacy after marriage.
She seemed aligned with everything I wanted—almost too perfectly. Initially, she said she couldn’t continue talking because her father was setting her up with someone else. But later, her family reached out to mine and expressed interest in proceeding.
My father was particularly enthusiastic about this match, as she was from a different city (a long-standing family preference), and pushed hard for us to move forward quickly. Despite my hesitation and desire to take more time, we ended up doing a **roka** and a **legal marriage** within days, primarily so that her immigration file for a visa/residency could begin.
**What Happened After:**
* I flew back to the US two days after the legal marriage (December 2024). We did **not consummate the marriage**.
* After coming back, I started noticing major red flags:
* Her behavior was controlling and immature.
* Her messages seemed scripted, as if taken from AI or pop culture tropes.
* Every call I made was being recorded without my consent.
* She became overly possessive, and communication felt inauthentic.
* I told her honestly that I needed time to process things, but her reaction was emotionally manipulative and immature.
* I tried multiple times to communicate openly, requesting we approach this maturely and truthfully—but she often twisted my words and presented me in a negative light to my parents.
* Her messages were curated to portray herself as the victim, even though I was just being vulnerable and asking for space and truth.**Current Situation:**
* It’s been nearly **5 months** since the legal marriage.
* We **have not lived together**, **have not consummated the marriage**, and have been **not in communication** for months now.
* Both families initially agreed to a **mutual annulment/divorce**, but her side has gone silent.
* Her father has been ill, which delayed things, but now there’s no clear communication from their end.
* My parents are suggesting I “wait it out,” but I am emotionally exhausted and feel stuck.**My Questions:**
1. Given that the marriage is **not consummated** and there’s been **no cohabitation**, can I apply for an **annulment** on my own? What are the legal grounds in India for annulment in this case?
2. If I choose to go for a **contested divorce**, what are the implications, especially as an NRI?
3. Is there any **NRI-specific legal help** or counsel I can reach out to for quick and effective resolution?
4. What can I do to protect myself from any **false claims**, especially since my calls were recorded?
5. Are there any **online resources or legal aid groups** that support men or NRIs in such cases?I genuinely wanted to build something real, but I now realize I may have been manipulated emotionally and rushed into a legal commitment. Any advice or suggestions would be truly appreciated.
Thank you.
-
DHi. Lawyer here. Sorry to hear about your situation. Will be glad to answer your queries at length, should you be comfortable. But for that, some internal facts need to be known. Please feel free to reach out to me for a discussion in the event you wish to.
Also, yes you can seek annulment on various grounds provided under law, including but not limited to impotency/no cohabitation. The rest can be discussed. Thanks. -
UNAL.
1. Get with a lawyer.
2. Annulments in India is hard. Usually only reason that I’ve seen is impotency of the guy. No cohabitation could be used.
3. Try to settle with mutual divorce. You have to live apart for a year.
4. If the girl does decide to go rouge, there’s plenty of fake cases she can file and get you involved in the system. All take 3-5 years to settle and flush out. Targeting NRI’s is the latest trend because they have assets in India that these women can go after.
5. Look up Fake 498a, Crpc 125. Those two are a definite. Others depend on the lawyer.
6. Gather all evidences of no dowry harassment and if she has a job, gather the paystubs.Good luck!
-
-
CI seems to be the case that her side of the family is waiting out for the one year window for annulment to close.
-
-
-
-
RMr Optimistic NRI . Sad , but now you are in a desi arrange marriage trap. Its not unusual that girls are ‘forced’ by their families to appear ‘Sanskari’ – and guys (typically poetic romantic NRIs) getting swayed .
Further legal marriage means – all consent or background everything cannot be disputed so easily for annulment (unless girl or you were alrd legally married earlier). Also its barely 5 months and no legally significant ground is present. So
take a deep breath, and come to terms with it.Suggest you settle down your emotional upheavals, talk to her, give it another try, let some spark fly, involve some intermediaries to counsel ‘shaadi ka matlab kya hota hai’ to the girl – and that may lead to some clear outcome. Do check if the girl is not suffering from critical mental illness (on medication for psychotic not psychiatric illness). If she is , its a separate matter – and you have grounds for annulment, but gather some evidences about it (thru medical shops, local jasoos, doctors, sarkari hospitals with psychiatric ward)
If it all fails, u still can claim how ‘adarsh’ and committed you were to your marriage and tried as much as possible to make it successful
Alternatively, if you really have time & interest on your side – pls get lawyers, courts, police etc involved – and do be sure opposite side will do the same, fight a nonsensical legal battle for years with no end, pay maintenance or settle out of courts , and all this while loose your youthful state. In your case , Courts will be super lenient to the Girl – so her lawyer can play it to call u in front of Judge every few months.
Think wisely before, in India context, you plan to proceed with divorce. Its just too complicated and frustrating out there …
-
