Seeking Advice for a Friend Going Through a Marital Crisis

Community Forums Legal Advice India Seeking Advice for a Friend Going Through a Marital Crisis

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #3516 Reply
      Desividhi5964
      Participant
        D
        Desividhi5964
        PARTICIPANT
        May 3, 2025 at 5:23 am
        I’m reaching out on behalf of a close friend who’s currently navigating a very tough personal situation. He got married just 4 months ago. Due to work commitments, his wife had to move back to Hyderabad almost immediately, while he stayed in Pune. They barely got to spend time together as a married couple.

        Now, unexpectedly, his wife has asked for a divorce, saying she couldn’t develop emotional attachment and doesn’t see a future in the marriage. This came as a shock to him. From the beginning, her interest in the relationship seemed limited, but he had hoped things would improve with time.

        What’s even harder is witnessing his family break down emotionally and physically under the strain. While initially heartbroken, he now feels emotionally detached too and is considering accepting the divorce and moving forward.

        He’s looking for clarity and guidance — legal, emotional, or practical — on how best to proceed in such a situation. Any advice from those who’ve seen or experienced something similar would be deeply appreciated.

        Please feel free to share your thoughts in the comments or via DM. Thank you in advance for your support.

      • #3519 Reply
        Desiknight9081
        Participant
          D
          Desiknight9081
          PARTICIPANT
          May 3, 2025 at 6:25 am
          Hi. I’m a Delhi based lawyer, with an extensive background experience in matrimonial matters. Since they haven’t been married for a year, let alone living apart for that period of time, a divorce petition cannot be filed at the moment. However, their marriage can be annulled basis the grounds for annulment provided under law.

          • #3521 Reply
            Desividhi5964
            Participant
              D
              Desividhi5964
              OP
              May 3, 2025 at 12:07 pm
              Thank you for your comment. Can you help with the grounds on which the marriage can buy annulled?

              • #3523 Reply
                Desiknight9081
                Participant
                  D
                  Desiknight9081
                  PARTICIPANT
                  May 3, 2025 at 12:12 pm
                  Lack of consent due to fraud/coercion etc, impotency, pregnancy from another person at the time of marriage etc

                  • #3526 Reply
                    Desividhi5964
                    Participant
                      D
                      Desividhi5964
                      OP
                      May 3, 2025 at 1:52 pm
                      Oh, ok. It doesn’t seem any of these reasons fits the grounds for annullment here in his case.
                      Any other suggestions!

                      • #3527 Reply
                        Desiknight9081
                        Participant
                          D
                          Desiknight9081
                          PARTICIPANT
                          May 3, 2025 at 1:58 pm
                          Annulment petition can only be filed under the grounds provided under law.

                • #3518 Reply
                  Supervignesh7888
                  Participant
                    S
                    Supervignesh7888
                    PARTICIPANT
                    May 3, 2025 at 8:10 am
                    Tell your friend he’s lucky — he should go for a mutually consented divorce immediately. Think of it as dodging a bullet.

                    • #3520 Reply
                      Desividhi5964
                      Participant
                        D
                        Desividhi5964
                        OP
                        May 3, 2025 at 12:08 pm
                        Absolutely!
                        However can the divorce petition be filled within a year of marriage? And also who should initiate divorce proceedings, his wife of himself?

                        • #3522 Reply
                          Supervignesh7888
                          Participant
                            S
                            Supervignesh7888
                            PARTICIPANT
                            May 3, 2025 at 1:40 pm
                            Absolutely. Your friend’s actually lucky — if the wife wants out this early, the smart thing is to go for a Mutual Consent Divorce under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act. Now, since the marriage hasn’t even completed a year, Section 14 kicks in, which normally doesn’t allow divorce filing within 12 months. But there’s a way around that — your friend can file an application along with the divorce petition, asking the court for permission citing “exceptional hardship” or “breakdown with no possibility of reconciliation.” The fact that they barely lived together, have no emotional connection, and she’s already checked out mentally, makes it an easy case for early permission.

                            Once that’s cleared, they can proceed with the 13B petition. Normally there’s a 6-month waiting period between filing and final hearing, but even that can be skipped if both parties apply to waive it — based on the 2017 Supreme Court ruling in Amardeep Singh v. Harveen Kaur. If both are on the same page, the whole thing can be wrapped up in about 30 to 60 days. Clean, fast, and no courtroom drama.

                            Now as for handling her — this isn’t about emotions or fairness anymore. It’s about closing this chapter without getting dragged into false cases, demands, or years of litigation. Your friend just needs to play it smart: stroke her ego a bit, keep the tone calm, don’t argue or get defensive, and present divorce as something that’s good for both. Say something like, “You’ve always been honest about your feelings and I respect that. No point dragging a marriage that’s not working. Let’s part ways peacefully — quick, quiet, and without legal mess.” That one line can get her to lower her guard.

                            Get a short settlement agreement signed stating neither side will claim maintenance or raise any issues later. If she cooperates, it’ll all be over fast. If she stalls, then your friend should still be the one to file first — that way, he controls the narrative and avoids being on the back foot later. But ideally, get her to agree, get her signature, and walk out with peace of mind intact.

                            And at last consult a good lawyer in same line-and-length before making any step forward.

                            • #3525 Reply
                              Desividhi5964
                              Participant
                                D
                                Desividhi5964
                                OP
                                May 3, 2025 at 1:46 pm
                                Hey, thanks a ton for this detailed post. Appreciate it a lot. Gives more clarity and is explained in a lucid manner.

                              • #3524 Reply
                                Desividhi5964
                                Participant
                                  D
                                  Desividhi5964
                                  OP
                                  May 8, 2025 at 9:38 am
                                  Hey, As you mentioned at the last that him filing the divorce will control the narrative and avoids being on the back foot later. Can you please clarify how filing for divorce from his end will put him at advantage?

                          • #3517 Reply
                            Desividhi5964
                            Participant
                              D
                              Desividhi5964
                              OP
                              May 4, 2025 at 12:16 pm
                              New info, They haven’t registered the marriage with the government portal. Means they don’t have a marriage certificate yet. Does this information hold any value in this case?

                          Viewing 3 reply threads
                          Reply To: Reply #3523 in Seeking Advice for a Friend Going Through a Marital Crisis
                          Your information:




                          Cancel