Temple in Dadar,Mumbai still thinks women are impure – My friend wasn’t allowed to enter

Community Forums Legal Advice India Temple in Dadar,Mumbai still thinks women are impure – My friend wasn’t allowed to enter

Viewing 9 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #5715 Reply
      Rapidnidhi3581
      Participant
        R
        Rapidnidhi3581
        PARTICIPANT
        April 29, 2025 at 12:38 pm
        This really pissed me off so just putting it out here. Recently went to the Swaminarayan Mandir opposite Dadar station with a lady friend. We had to meet a swami whose office was inside the temple, near the area where they prepare prasad.

        Everything seemed fine till the staff just stopped my friend and said “women not allowed” beyond that point. No proper explanation, nothing. Just a flat-out no. She wasn’t on her period, she was dressed properly in Indian traditional clothes, we were respectful and all. Still, she was denied entry.

        From what we could make out, it’s probably because that was the prasad preparation area, and women are seen as “impure” in such places. It’s 2025, and we’re in Mumbai, not some rural backlane. How are temples still allowed to follow this Brahmanical nonsense that sees women as less pure or spiritually unfit?

        Like what even is this logic? Just being a woman is enough reason to get banned from a religious space?

        This is just another example of how patriarchal and outdated some so-called traditions are, and they keep getting protected under the name of religion. Honestly sick of it. No one questions it, no one talks about it, and women just silently face it all the time.

        If anyone knows where we can formally report this kind of discrimination or raise awareness, please comment. This needs to stop being normal.

      • #5724 Reply
        Expertdude8118
        Participant
          E
          Expertdude8118
          PARTICIPANT
          April 29, 2025 at 12:48 pm
          It’s not about impurity.

          There are many temples which have tradition of no women entry. Learn a bit about history of that temple before making such accusations.

          Here are examples of some temples which put restrictions on men

          Kamakhya Temple (during Ambubachi Mela) – Assam
          Restriction: During the Ambubachi Mela, men are not allowed into the temple for three days, symbolizing the goddess’s menstruation.

          Brahma Temple, Pushkar – Rajasthan
          Restriction: Married men are not allowed to enter the sanctum sanctorum.

          Mata Temple, Muzaffarpur – Bihar
          Restriction: Men are not allowed during the 3-day menstrual cycle of the goddess.

          Bhagati Maa Temple, Kanya Kumari – Tamil Nadu
          Restriction: In certain areas of the temple, unmarried men are not allowed, as the goddess is considered a virgin

          P.S: I am atheist by the way, not sure why you people are crazy to enter a temple when as per the story and mythology — the gods themselves doesn’t want you(women) to enter.

        • #5723 Reply
          Quickram6703
          Participant
            Q
            Quickram6703
            PARTICIPANT
            April 29, 2025 at 12:49 pm
            You can’t change it my guy you can’t it will only change when the older generation dies and newer generation takes over temples

          • #5722 Reply
            Supervipin5890
            Participant
              S
              Supervipin5890
              PARTICIPANT
              April 29, 2025 at 12:51 pm
              “Patriarchal Brahamical Nonsense”

              lmao

            • #5720 Reply
              Fierceprakash8781
              Participant
                F
                Fierceprakash8781
                PARTICIPANT
                April 29, 2025 at 12:53 pm
                try entering a mosque. Every place has its traditions better to respect it.

              • #5721 Reply
                Desishubham8881
                Participant
                  D
                  Desishubham8881
                  PARTICIPANT
                  April 29, 2025 at 12:53 pm
                  bro kuch mandiro ke apni ek story hoti hai jis wajah se vo baney te for eg read about sabrimala mandir womens are not allowed because lord ayyappa was a celibate thats why womens are not allowed and their is a temple in rajasthan brahma temple mens are not allowed their because of a reason . So my friend its not about patriarchy or discrimination .

                  • #5727 Reply
                    Expertdude8118
                    Participant
                      E
                      Expertdude8118
                      PARTICIPANT
                      April 29, 2025 at 12:57 pm
                      He/she like — main to ghusunga jabardasti,
                      Aur pooja karke hi rahunga,even if that God/Guru doesn’t want to be worshipped by me on certain days. Ase kase wo mujh se pooja nahi karwayenge —

                    • #5726 Reply
                      Silentpanda7593
                      Participant
                        S
                        Silentpanda7593
                        PARTICIPANT
                        April 29, 2025 at 2:10 pm
                        Are you talking about the Brahma temple in Pushkar ?

                        • #5729 Reply
                          Desishubham8881
                          Participant
                            D
                            Desishubham8881
                            PARTICIPANT
                            April 29, 2025 at 6:32 pm
                            yup i dont know if its true or not but once a teacher was telling us about brahma temple

                      • #5719 Reply
                        Mightyeagle7543
                        Participant
                          M
                          Mightyeagle7543
                          PARTICIPANT
                          April 29, 2025 at 12:56 pm

                        • #5718 Reply
                          Expertninja6581
                          Participant
                            E
                            Expertninja6581
                            PARTICIPANT
                            April 29, 2025 at 1:00 pm
                            It’s a religious place – it’s all about beliefs. Let them practice in peace, and find yours in a more suitable place for yourself.

                          • #5717 Reply
                            Rapidsomesh2476
                            Participant
                              R
                              Rapidsomesh2476
                              PARTICIPANT
                              April 29, 2025 at 1:03 pm
                              Why go to swaminarayan temple when you don’t understand their customs? Swami Narayan was supposed to be a brahmachari. . Don’t like it, go to some other temple.
                              The temple is not a public place, it’s a private space.

                              • #5725 Reply
                                Rapidnidhi3581
                                Participant
                                  R
                                  Rapidnidhi3581
                                  OP
                                  April 29, 2025 at 2:29 pm
                                  From what I know women are allowed in temple,I’m not making it up but she wasn’t allowed in the office which was situated next to prasad making place

                                  • #5728 Reply
                                    Rapidsomesh2476
                                    Participant
                                      R
                                      Rapidsomesh2476
                                      PARTICIPANT
                                      April 29, 2025 at 2:33 pm
                                      Man, the office is not even a religious place. Why did you feel the need to label it as a religious misogyny issue? I could see the problem if a woman was not allowed into the prayer hall or sanctum. But office?

                                      • #5730 Reply
                                        Rapidnidhi3581
                                        Participant
                                          R
                                          Rapidnidhi3581
                                          OP
                                          April 29, 2025 at 2:38 pm
                                          I’ve encountered such thing for the first time. The office was itself in temple premises but for the work we went there I was dependent on my senior lady, and just because of gender restricting entry is something I couldn’t figure we’ll,I’m not criticising hinduism even womens aren’t allowed in masjids, but this was kind of a cultural shock to me maybe I’m not knowledgeable entirely about traditional beliefs or the core reason behind it of swami Narayan temple but it felt wrong from inside.

                                          • #5731 Reply
                                            Rapidsomesh2476
                                            Participant
                                              R
                                              Rapidsomesh2476
                                              PARTICIPANT
                                              April 29, 2025 at 2:46 pm
                                              Entry in the office being restricted to men only is as absurd as it sounds. Maybe that particular employee was a misogynist. Although swaminarayan temples are very liberal in my experience.

                                              • #5732 Reply
                                                Rapidnidhi3581
                                                Participant
                                                  R
                                                  Rapidnidhi3581
                                                  OP
                                                  April 29, 2025 at 2:57 pm
                                                  The person who directed us their and the watchman everyone said the entry is allowed for only men it wasn’t one person only but when I went there and saw she wasn’t allowed there because at that place they were cooking prasad for the mandir left me stunned because I had heard this before in movies and stories that woman brings impurity but seeing this today was total shock although I’ve not been to swaminarayan temple so can’t comment on that

                                      • #5716 Reply
                                        Subhashtiger265
                                        Participant
                                          S
                                          Subhashtiger265
                                          PARTICIPANT
                                          April 29, 2025 at 3:12 pm
                                          Follow law of the land, simple.
                                          Not everything is about feminism and gender discrimination.
                                          Did you ever posted about male stag entry being denied in almost all pubs across every metro cities (while couples and female stags allowed). They dont have any real logic.

                                          The point being you follow the law of the land. Also as stated by someone in comments, each temple has a backstory and some rituals, let them follow that. Be respectful. Its as simple as that. Nothing more nothing less.

                                      Viewing 9 reply threads
                                      Reply To: Reply #5731 in Temple in Dadar,Mumbai still thinks women are impure – My friend wasn’t allowed to enter
                                      Your information:




                                      Cancel