Weakness in HC’s Argument on Right to Privacy in UCC Case

Community Forums Legal Advice India Weakness in HC’s Argument on Right to Privacy in UCC Case

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    Posts
    • #51417 Reply
      User_0b4dd3aa
      Participant
        U
        User_0b4dd3aa
        PARTICIPANT
        February 19, 2025 at 1:00 pm
        In the Uttarakhand HC case on UCC, the petitioner argued privacy violations, but the court dismissed it, saying:

        “You are brazenly living together without marriage. What privacy is invaded?”

        India still has a regressive mindset where pre-marital relationships are frowned upon, sometimes even leading to ostracization or violence. Opposite genders might also live together without being in a relationship. Even if I am in one, I don’t want the government maintaining a registry of all my past relationships. Also, importantly, the clause on maintainance will discourage couples who want to test the water before a marriage or even those who are just into no – strings attached relationships.

        1. What are the weaknesses in the HC’s argument from a legal standpoint?

        2. What is the best legal reasoning to challenge this law and get it stayed or revoked? Is that feasible, and how long could it take, given that it puts many people at risk?

        Would love insights from legal minds!

        [UCC live in ](https://theprint.in/india/uttarakhand-ucc-how-is-registration-of-live-in-relations-invasion-of-privacy-hc-asks/2500522/)

      • #51418 Reply
        Luckybear8410
        Participant
          L
          Luckybear8410
          PARTICIPANT
          February 19, 2025 at 1:22 pm
          Our courts are unfortunately a fucking joke. The same holds good for the moral science lecture on the BeerBiceps SC hearing too

      Viewing 1 reply thread
      Reply To: Reply #51418 in Weakness in HC’s Argument on Right to Privacy in UCC Case
      Your information:




      Cancel