What’s the catch?

Community Forums Legal Advice India What’s the catch?

Viewing 11 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #58699 Reply
      User_dd6de939
      Participant
        U
        User_dd6de939
        PARTICIPANT
        February 7, 2025 at 11:28 am
        Long story short. Marriage broke down prior to consummation and cohabitation but was registered for Visa purposes. It was registered under the special marriage act. The girl called it off and filed two cases on me.

        One for nullifying the marriage and the other for damages, to cover the cost for their engagement event. These two cases were referred to counseling where I explained I had no issues continuing the relationship, she was often absent. Now both cases are posted for mediation.

        Circa one year later, I came to terms with that fact she’s no returning. I filed an OP for divorce on the grounds of desertion and non-consummation of the marriage. Also mentioned cruelty.

        Now suddenly after the initial hearing and referral for counseling (again), girls lawyer wants us to go for mutual consent divorce even though we had offered this to them before but they didn’t want the divorce tag.

        I know there’s a catch but my non lawyer brain can’t figure it out, so I thought to ask you guys. Why suddenly are they ok with mutual consent and let alone divorce when they weren’t before :/

      • #58712 Reply
        Saratseeker418
        Participant
          S
          Saratseeker418
          PARTICIPANT
          February 7, 2025 at 12:13 pm
          Because they know they aren’t going to get very far. It’s best to document everything before you agree.

        • #58711 Reply
          Utkarshseeker448
          Participant
            U
            Utkarshseeker448
            PARTICIPANT
            February 7, 2025 at 12:37 pm
            The catch here might be that it would be to settle on an amount and call for a divorce.

            Unless they are saints and want a hassle free process.

          • #58710 Reply
            Expertfox3531
            Participant
              E
              Expertfox3531
              PARTICIPANT
              February 7, 2025 at 12:44 pm
              Not a lawyer

              They are thinking about themselves. Their reputation, their lawyer should have informed them that their case is not strong. (Based on your information) So, it’s better for them to play the nice girl infront of judge. For now that’s what going on their mind. But remember your ex wife is a walking time bomb. She has already broken the marriage and it’s highly possible she will do it again even if you two get back together.

            • #58709 Reply
              User_549c76e4
              Participant
                U
                User_549c76e4
                PARTICIPANT
                February 7, 2025 at 12:44 pm
                This one’s easy. A new (and possibly naive) suitor has entered the scene and they want to close the deal ASAP.

              • #58708 Reply
                User_44aeded4
                Participant
                  U
                  User_44aeded4
                  PARTICIPANT
                  February 7, 2025 at 1:18 pm
                  Just be glad she didn’t file a fake rape/gang-rape, unnatural sex, dowry, false promise and coersion cases on you and your family. In fact, of all the cases I’ve seen this sounds the most tame.

                  You’re not an Indian citizen, the marriage was not consummated, they’ve delayed and wasted enough of your time… why do you care what some corrupt asshole in a court thinks? 

                  Get out of the country and never trust Indians again, at least as far as marriage and money matters go.

                • #58707 Reply
                  Quickguru4523
                  Participant
                    Q
                    Quickguru4523
                    PARTICIPANT
                    February 7, 2025 at 1:49 pm
                    I think the catch is that if they lose a contested divorce and you are in the clear it will work against the girl her reputation will be tarnished which will effect her prospective future search for another groom as the judgement is uploaded by courts on their public domain but with mutual divorce because of the nature of being a settlement between two parties the reasons in judgement don’t come on public domain

                  • #58706 Reply
                    Happybear2986
                    Participant
                      H
                      Happybear2986
                      PARTICIPANT
                      February 7, 2025 at 2:55 pm
                      Because there is space for negotiations and compensation in mutually agreed divorce. If you got divorce on cruelty she is not getting anything. So they are trying to make the best out of it.

                    • #58705 Reply
                      Sujatapanda204
                      Participant
                        S
                        Sujatapanda204
                        PARTICIPANT
                        February 7, 2025 at 5:34 pm
                        Don’t change your stand, for MC you need to pull back the existing divorce petition and if you do that all your hardwork will be in vain.

                        Once you withdraw your current divorce petition another party is under no obligation to agree for MC.

                      • #58704 Reply
                        User_8b18e4c5
                        Participant
                          U
                          User_8b18e4c5
                          PARTICIPANT
                          February 7, 2025 at 11:56 pm
                          NAL.

                          Figure out if they are ready for a Mutual without any exchange of money. Not a penny. Get a MOU or similar. Let them withdraw their cases . Mention all conditions in MOU. If nothing seems off in these discussions , they seem happy with the deal , then take mutual . In 6-12 months – you will be free. 

                          If they change mind,  you are anyway in for along fight . Plan again.

                        • #58701 Reply
                          Brightwolf5745
                          Participant
                            B
                            Brightwolf5745
                            PARTICIPANT
                            February 8, 2025 at 8:25 am
                            There’s a saying in court. A bad settlement is much better than a good judgement. You have an opportunity to end divorce cases in a way that many do not have. You can settle all disputes, including maintenance, through compromise. You will save time and money. But of course, considering the fact that they approached you generally means you have a very strong case. Use it to your advantage and get a mutual divorce.

                          • #58700 Reply
                            Indiangargi2466
                            Participant
                              I
                              Indiangargi2466
                              PARTICIPANT
                              February 10, 2025 at 7:26 am
                              You can either drag the matter for years in court or settle with mutual divorce. Post this you can file for defamation against the family for that smear campaign they did. Or you can do it right away and strengthen your negotiating power.

                              The only reason they are backing off is that you guys didn’t live under the same roof, otherwise they would had filed all the other cases and you’d be left helpless then.

                          Viewing 11 reply threads
                          Reply To: Reply #58709 in What’s the catch?
                          Your information:




                          Cancel