- This topic has 55 replies, 41 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 3 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
AA fire that broke out in the residential bungalow of a Delhi high court judge resulted in recovery of a huge pile of cash, sending shock waves in judicial corridors and forcing the Supreme Court collegium led by CJI Sanjiv Khanna to decide to transfer him to another HC.
Wah 🙏🙏👏👏👏 just transfer!
But seriously why cannot our judges be arrested?
All his cases need to be opened up and retried. -
-
SCuz all of them are just the same? Judges are appointed by other judges (at least in SC afaik) they appoint someone who’s dada, mamu, chachu, fufa someone who was already a judge. Judges are people with a lot of power and not many consequences. Another one is that female judge in Atul Subhash’s case. Despite all the information and outrage against her, the courts didn’t do shit to her. That’s how it works.
-
UShe abetted suicide together with the wife. And still passing judgements on other people?
Update: Fire chief said no cash was found. So all that talk of transfer was smoke and mirrors. Did they split the cash? But then again, judges know how judges work, so he probably wouldnt have kept his black money at home.
-
-
EYes you are correct. All the judges in SC belongs to only 2 family tree. You can just Google it, its there.
-
-
-
-
MA judgement by a HC / SC judge sets precedent and is effectively law. Several subsequent cases would have been addressed using judgements passed by the concerned judge.
Revisiting all judgements then becomes a major issue as it will upset the life of considerable number of people.
-
UI am trying to understand:
Soo, for the convenience of people who were wrongfully exonerated by bribed judge, we need to keep the judge and they paid off verdicts will be considered effectively law for foreseeable future, even applying to cases the judge was not bribed for.
All the more reason the judge should be investigated properly?
-
DRead about the collegium system. Now you will understand the tussle between them and the current government.
-
UOligarchy: Its like monarchy/dictatorship, but instead of one person to hold all the power, a small number of people hold all the power. In Rome, this was called the senate. In modern India, Its called the collegium. These people decide who gets promoted to collegium. They are unelected rulers of the people.
-
-
MA judge can be investigated / tried as an individual. His judgements may undergo a review – but the basic guidance is that – unless a specific review is requested – there will not be blanket review of past judgements.
If what you state needs to be applied then several judgements by multiple judges in their last weeks of service would need to be reviewed. Many judges openly indicated strong personal biases in interviews or other forums in the first weeks after retiring. These biases would definitely influenced the judgements.
-
-
-
-
UIts funny how they didn’t publish the most intriguing part, the amount of money found. They conveniently didn’t publish that. Corrupt fuckers
-
ASome must have been given to fire brigade and some to Delhi Police.
The rest shifted to state bank of India, chandani chok branch 😂😂😂😂😂-
-
MReports suggest between 10-15 crore. Also latest news is that the fire force didn’t find any money at all lmaoo. Boys are in action it looks like
-
-
-
-
-
SMost corrupted system. But still these judges are given respects and facilities. As per my analysis 70% judges are corrupted.
-
-
-
-
-
-
WWho will investigate ? Cbi ( corrupt) , Police ( local gangsters with uniform ) , also there was an SA case against an SC judge and guess who was on the bench of judges that delivered the judgement? The accused himself delivered the judgement
SC in between make some typical comments in favor of public and against gov just to give public the idea we are here for you
Whole system is corrupt , and they all party together
-
-
AMPs, MLAs have been sent to prison. Debarred from contesting elections for a lifetime (it was the judiciary who gave this verdict). Legislature ✔️
Ministers have been sent to jail, IAS/PCS officers are suspended/terminated and jailed. Executive ✔️
How many SC/HC Judges have been impeached/removed since Independence? Zero, Absolutely None. Judiciary ❌
This should give you an idea.
They were allowed to form a collegium, judges will appoint judges leading to ‘Uncle Judge Syndrome’ and the President is bound to give her assent. Nowhere in a sane democracy this should be allowed.
-
-
AAn ex CJI was accused of sexual harassment, around 5 years ago, he formed a committee to investigate, guess who was present in that committee? He himself! And he gave himself the clean chit! This is CJI we are talking about not some low level sessions court judge. (You can read about it on google)
‘Rules for you, not for me’
-
-
-
-
-
LThe judiciary’s immunity from accountability and its elitism didn’t emerge overnight—it’s a legacy of its original purpose. The British established a structured legal system, replacing India’s diverse indigenous traditions, not to serve justice but to maintain control. It was a tool for suppressing dissent and revolts, treating the local population as second-class citizens while upholding colonial rule.
After independence, the country became free, but the system remained largely unchanged. Politicians inherited a ready-made structure and chose to run it as it was. That’s why, even today, our judiciary retains much of its colonial character—distant, elitist, and corrupt.
The judiciary is nothing more than a club of elites who see the common man as a slave, a laborer, or a second-class citizen. Simply put, power has just shifted from white skin to brown skin, so questioning it doesn’t really mean much.
-
-
-
RIf all the BJP could do was a name changing to BNS, there is not much hope. One could have a jury system like in the US, countries of Europe were common people are part of the judgement giving system.
Also, Swiss style referendums are essential to a working democracy. Currently, our constitution can not be changed easily and the courts hide behind “basic structure” argument for anything critical. Referendums take away that argument. It also gives power back to the people instead of being concentrated amongst a group of oligarchs.
-
-
-
UWhile i agree the judiciary is rotten from the inside, the logic behind it is:
Because the judges have to first and foremost not live in fear of their lives so that they can pass a honest and fair judgment in every case. If every judge was afraid of being investigated and arrested all the time, he would not be able to exercise independence and his powers will be abused no matter what the actual problem is.
-
-
-
STheir corruption is only revealed by accident. There was another case of mistaken identify of a HC judge Nirmala where the bribe money was given to another judge with the same name. Google it.
Indian judiciary has created a closed system for themselves whereby while they will pass judgement on every single entity in India, but if culprit is from their own community they have their own set of rules.
Few years back there was a rape case on a SC judge, SC promptly gave a clean chit. For a normal man, there is a definite jail time involved even if a case is fake.While they ask every politician to reveal their source of income, but this exercise is optional for milords.
-
UWho’s gonna arrest and convict them.
Police protect other corrupt Police , Judges protect other Judges coz basically they don’t want the department as a whole to look bad.
On top of all this , our stupid constitution protects everyone in the government…as a person who studied and analysed the constitution , Judges , IAS officers , Police and Politicans are bulletproof. You cannot even touch their hair as long as they hold the post.
They tried to give them security to do their “Jobs” , ended giving them immunity and a free pass to do any – everything in their power…
It’s failed book
-
-
MFirst if he is convinced all his cases will have to be reopened.
Police politician and judicial officers will all be in problem if things spirel out.And well innocent people this guy send behind jail all will come for govt and justice system head.
And many more problems will be their.
So its better if you are not from rich family to keep your head down and treat it as nothing happened you didn’t see or listen about this.
And if you wanna talk about this make sure you have a way to go to other countries so you don’t go to Jail.
-
-
-
-
BWhy? Hmm have you ever heard in any political parties poll platform anywhere in India two things: a) Reform of the police system and making them professional and independent b) Reform the Judicial system to make it fast, efficient, hire more judges and make them independent? Ever? No?
Why? Because it is in any political parties interest to grab on to power and Police is its muscleman and executioners and slow and corrupt Judiciary is necessary to ensure they will never be punished and in fact use it to further their agenda. This is controlling the sheep 101.
Mandir Masjid Bulldozer? Yes!. The Police/Politician/Judiciary is the Shit Sandwich Indians eat everyday.
-
-
RIf news channels or newspapers publish this, courts can put contempt of court on them, fucking them hard, + everyone who’s been to any court knows if you want your way out ASAP you need to bribe these judges, and every official at every level
+ Mi lords are the ones deciding fate of someone’s life so they won’t let one of their breed go down as all of them do the same thing
-
-
-
ROur justice system is still based on colonial dna. Which was designed to keep the judicial system and govt safe and not for welfare of society.
As they just wanted the public to believe that justice will be served and keep waiting for it rather than taking action on their own.
Unfortunately this was not changed once India got independence. Hence you can’t question judge or judicial system. -
QDoesn’t this just prove that they are basically just using a loophole from our Constitution which says that the Judiciary works independently and separately from the Executive and Legislature?
Meaning those who create the laws (L) and those who implement the laws (E) cannot look into the work (in this case, crimes) of those who ensure laws are applied fairly (J).
Clear violation of ethics and trust, but I’m guessing they’re protected by that?
-
-
