- This topic has 40 replies, 26 voices, and was last updated 1 year, 4 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
-
-
QIn my opinion which is a really controversial one, when these gangrapes and gruesome murders related to rapes started popping up then only people cared. No one actually cares just about rape and they dismiss it really quickly. So instead of relying on a broken system and a broken society, we need to prepare ourselves for the worst.
-
UAs bad as rape is, its not the worst thing that can happen. If rape and murder had the same punishment, it would incentivize the rapist to murder the victim to cover up the rape.
Objectivity speaking, the victim and the family would be better of if the victim is alive even after going through such a horrible thing.
-
-
-
-
UPremeditated murder carries a bigger sentence because you planned the murder.
Crime of passion is when you catch a guy having sex with your wife and you shoot him in the head. That’s not premeditated so it’s crime of passion, it’s instinctual.
In the US at least, crime of passion tends to bring you manslaughter charge. Manslaughter sentence is lower than murder.
-
-
CYou get life imprisonment to death penalty for premeditated murder while it is 7 to 10 years in jail if it is Crime of Passion
-
-
CLegally Crime of Passion needs to be instantaneous. Husband sees wife with a stranger and immediately attacks them with an iron rode that was nearby and kills them. There is no planning or thoughts to kill or hurt them. It is instinctive and emotional
In India, most cases that are shown as crime of passion are premeditated. Husband or lover knows his partner is cheating with such person and thinks about it for hours or days , then makes up plan to kill them and then commit suicide or surrender to police or escape
A famous case is about Navy officer who confronted his wife’s lover. It was made into Hindi movie Rustom starring Akshay Kumar
The lover called his wife a whore so he went back to his home , got his gun , returned to wife’s lover and killed him. The whole process of going to his house and getting gun took one hour. His adv tried crime of passion defence but court ruled that ,the fact he went to get gun from home shows there was planning involved and thus is premeditated.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
UAnd what is the worse thing that can happen? Just curious.
Also wanted to know your gender if you don’t mind.
-
-
-
-
-
CWhy is rape worse than murder. Willful planned murder usually only get life sentence. Is rape worse than Murder?
Unless the rape leads to death or victim being in comma, I don’t see the point of giving Death penalty
Punishment of rape should be done taking into account of circumstances, the force used, the relationship between victim and rapists
-
-
-
BBecause the term rape is too vague to have a blanket punishment.. also in many cases , there is no physical evidence and it’s all circumstantial.. plus many fake cases..
Even in gang rape , not everytime they get death penalty but only in rarest of rare cases
-
UIf there is no physical evidence and it’s circumstantial then why even jail time? Let the poor bhechara man go.
The question was if it is proved then why not death penalty.
-
-
-
-
-
-
VDo you want all fake/false rape accused to be hanged provided they were unable to prove their innocence. Do you think it’s fair ?
-
BU do realise that percentage of fake cases range very low than the actual rape and harassment that goes on in this country
-
VDid I say otherwise, what kind of sick uneducated person are you ? You couldn’t comprehend my simple statement, and you came here to spin off things.
Typical narcissistic indoctinated behaviour.
If i have to do what you did then answer my question
Are you happy to hang 7% of innocent men accused of false rape, because those men life dosent matter ?
-
-
-
UFalse and Fake are two different terminologies, with drastic differences in law, so don’t put them as “Fake/False” It’s weird to see, how even a news handle is using these terms wrongly.
-
-
-
CThe unfortunate truth is that the only death penalties handed out are those that come to media attention.
The second thing is that the law isn’t favoring men, it doesn’t even recognize that they can be raped, a lot of times the evidence is very circumstantial and questionable altogether, but in a he said she said case she will always be believed, start hanging them all on accusations alone and you’ll have the whole 498A shit show all over again with women abusing the law to settle personal grudges.
Also the constitution protects you against inhuman and cruel punishments, pretty sure the death penalty comes under that. The last two major hangings were kasab and the nirbhaya culprits, one wasn’t Indian and a Terrorist responsible for 100s of deaths, the latter made noise in media that’s all, i
-
Ucoz India is a place where the law is biased against men and a mere accusation of rape can have men make rounds of courts and pay millions even when not convicted …
In India women centric laws are misused to settle for big amounts with quiet support of judges and shady lawyers …….
India is a place where a woman who lived with u for a year may accuse u of rape under the prestext of marriage if the relationship turns sour ……..
-
-
-
SCommitting murder in the course of rape is considered rarest of rare and death sentence is mandatory, if peoved. The legal reason for denying death penalty to rapists is to dissuade them from committing murder of the victim. If the rapist think he is going to be hanged for his crime, he might murder the victim as no further punishment can be placed upon him.
-
-
-
