Can one change the court if a magistrate is biased and seems to have a tie-up with the opposite party

Community Forums Legal Advice India Can one change the court if a magistrate is biased and seems to have a tie-up with the opposite party

Viewing 2 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #30597 Reply
      Sapanmaster587
      Participant
        S
        Sapanmaster587
        PARTICIPANT
        March 21, 2025 at 3:32 pm
        What can one do if a magistrate is clearly biased against him/her and seems to have a tie-up with the opposite party? Defence has strong evidence proving their innocence, but it feels like the magistrate has already decided to convict. I know they can appeal in case if conviction, but is there any way to change the court or get a different judge before the verdict?

        He’s a CJM.

      • #30599 Reply
        Wisepriya7529
        Participant
          W
          Wisepriya7529
          PARTICIPANT
          March 21, 2025 at 3:45 pm
          File an application before the district judge stating that you have lost faith in the presiding officer and would like to change.
          Most likely it will get rejected and your case will go back to the same court, but it will buy some time. After this if you really want to drag it you can appeal the application in high court/supreme court. Your chances of success are slim, but by the time it’s decided judge may get transferred and in the interim period your trial would get stayed.

          • #30601 Reply
            Sapanmaster587
            Participant
              S
              Sapanmaster587
              OP
              March 21, 2025 at 3:49 pm
              In the meantime the proceedings will be suspended or it’ll continue?

          • #30598 Reply
            Swiftgirish7560
            Participant
              S
              Swiftgirish7560
              PARTICIPANT
              March 21, 2025 at 3:58 pm
              Without any evidence just assumptions won’t help in this, general remarks etc made by the judge won’t help, once the judgement comes you may file an appeal in higher courts.

              If you file an application against the present judge you will have to prove concrete conflict of interest or any relationship with other party, then the judge maybe changed.

              • #30600 Reply
                Sapanmaster587
                Participant
                  S
                  Sapanmaster587
                  OP
                  March 21, 2025 at 4:08 pm
                  I am asking this for one of my close relative. The problem is he’s stuck here for the case, lost his job, it’s still in the evidence stage and the whole appeal process is going to atleast take 2 more years.

                  Additionally his bank accounts are freezed for this case so he’s not going for quashing.

                  • #30602 Reply
                    Swiftgirish7560
                    Participant
                      S
                      Swiftgirish7560
                      PARTICIPANT
                      March 21, 2025 at 5:04 pm
                      He may file separate Petition for interim relief, these things mostly depend on case to case basis.

                      • #30603 Reply
                        Sapanmaster587
                        Participant
                          S
                          Sapanmaster587
                          OP
                          March 21, 2025 at 5:05 pm
                          I appreciate your help.

                Viewing 2 reply threads
                Reply To: Can one change the court if a magistrate is biased and seems to have a tie-up with the opposite party
                Your information: