Company paid excess PF, wants the money back which I don’t have

Community Forums Legal Advice India Company paid excess PF, wants the money back which I don’t have

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    Posts
    • #72234 Reply
      User_49351f6f
      Participant
        U
        User_49351f6f
        PARTICIPANT
        January 17, 2025 at 7:41 pm
        Context: been unemployed over the last few months. I decided to withdraw my PF from my past employer – a PSU with its own PF trust.

        I received the money, post which I wrote to the company asking for the PF account statement (in my mind it was akin to getting a salary slip) for acknowledgement.

        They didn’t respond. I spent the money to meet financial requirements.

        After 2 weeks, I get a call from the finance department saying they didn’t withhold TDS (around 1L) and want me to refund that money.

        I don’t have the money, and I am particularly irritated that I took the effort to follow-up for a receipt which they ignored. And now they expect me to refund it immediately.

        I don’t have money, will there be any legal implications? Please help.

        I don’t have any issues giving the money back, but I don’t have it. Won’t be having that much for the near future too.

      • #72235 Reply
        Saratseeker418
        Participant
          S
          Saratseeker418
          PARTICIPANT
          January 18, 2025 at 3:00 am
          Withdrawal of PF attracts TDS and is liable to tax as though it was income earned subject to some exceptions. In your case since TDS is sought to be deducted you are not part of the exception.

          The company will suffer consequences for non deduction from the IT department but ultimately you will need to pay the tax which would generally be at a rate higher than the TDS. You will also be liable to pay the company the excess money received.

          • #72236 Reply
            User_49351f6f
            Participant
              U
              User_49351f6f
              OP
              January 18, 2025 at 3:20 am
              Thank you! According to information I received they have paid TDS, but didn’t deduct it from my final settlement. So from IT perspective it is ok? Either way I file my taxes with income as received. And since I have been unemployed for most part of the year, I don’t have any tax liability post deductions

        Viewing 1 reply thread
        Reply To: Company paid excess PF, wants the money back which I don’t have
        Your information: