Friend has an abusive family, I gave her a place to stay for one day

Community Forums Legal Advice India Friend has an abusive family, I gave her a place to stay for one day

Viewing 9 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #65999 Reply
      User_c7fcd5b2
      Participant
        U
        User_c7fcd5b2
        PARTICIPANT
        January 26, 2025 at 6:06 pm
        So my friend, (21F), called me in great distress crying on the phone, and asking if could she come stay at my place. I live with my parents too. I was hesitant to reply initially because I had no context, so she got angry and hung up, still crying. I was worried so I tried calling back but no reply. A while later she texted saying that her father and brothers beat her up really badly, she couldn’t even think straight because of the pain. So I said of course, you can come, and that text conversation went on for a bit.

        So she came and stayed, her father dropped her at the gate of the complex I live, since he wanted to verify that she wasn’t wandering off anywhere else, and was actually going to her friend’s house. She was really injured, she had bruises and swelling on her hand, forehead, and her knee, and scratches in other places. However she said this was the first time her father has actually physically abused her, though it happens often with the brothers. So we helped her out with ice packs etc. and she stayed the night, and the next day, and left approximately 24 hrs after she came. Her father came to pick her up at the gate, and had apparently expressed his disapproval the previous day itself, while dropping her off, that she had made this matter known to people outside the family. The matter of her getting beaten up by them.

        After going home, I wanted to text her to ask for some photos she took while she was here. And I noticed that she has deleted entire messages in our chat, where she’s spoken about them hurting her, or that anything was wrong in the household. Only my replies remain, which sound absurdly concerned, without context.

        Now I’m suddenly scared if her father chooses to spin this tale into me and my family forcing her to come here, maybe even kidnapping her against her will, and turning her against her parents. No one visited us, no one reliable saw her coming and going, it’s just our word against her father and the family. In his anger and fear that someone outside knows, he might do it. For context, he is a pretty influential person.
        Is this possible,
        and if so what should I prepare for?

        If I left any gaps in the story please tell me, I’m not thinking too clearly while writing this. I’m sorry for the unorganised paragraphs, and would appreciate any advice.

      • #66008 Reply
        Sapnathinker502
        Participant
          S
          Sapnathinker502
          PARTICIPANT
          January 26, 2025 at 6:18 pm
          I think the father is only trying to hide any evidence against himself.

        • #66007 Reply
          Luckyishant8759
          Participant
            L
            Luckyishant8759
            PARTICIPANT
            January 26, 2025 at 6:19 pm
            You’re probably worrying about it too much. It’s also possible that she deleted the messages because her father feels that way about these things going out of the house and figured it won’t go further if she deletes it. Or maybe she was embarrassed.

            From what you said, they might not want to make a bigger deal about this and have more people know, but in case it does come to what you say, your one sided messages would hopefully seem to give at least some context. Where necessary, deleted messages that were delivered could be recovered, especially in criminal matters. And the call records should also reflect that she contacted you first. There also might be some cameras that would show her father dropping her and picking her up.

          • #66006 Reply
            Aravguru227
            Participant
              A
              Aravguru227
              PARTICIPANT
              January 26, 2025 at 6:22 pm
              Dude cut her off. You might become a scapegoat. The issue involves her family and probably someone else you don’t know about.
              Its very absurd why her parents would drop her at your place. And what would she gain from staying at yours!! Its not like she ran away in anger or fear. They came to drop her. So it speaks good of the parents. Its more likely she is not telling the truth to either the parents or you.

              • #66012 Reply
                User_dd3322d1
                Participant
                  U
                  User_dd3322d1
                  PARTICIPANT
                  January 26, 2025 at 7:15 pm
                  Seconded

              • #66005 Reply
                User_0a2cc9b2
                Participant
                  U
                  User_0a2cc9b2
                  PARTICIPANT
                  January 26, 2025 at 6:31 pm
                  Everything is fine but be careful if you are a guy, it won’t take a long time to portray you as the person at fault for calling her to your place, and even if you are a girl preferably stay out of it, if you want to avoid unnecessary legal trouble

                • #66004 Reply
                  Epicnaresh9698
                  Participant
                    E
                    Epicnaresh9698
                    PARTICIPANT
                    January 26, 2025 at 6:48 pm
                    Seems sus. Why would her father leave her with you?

                    • #66011 Reply
                      User_c7fcd5b2
                      Participant
                        U
                        User_c7fcd5b2
                        OP
                        January 26, 2025 at 7:04 pm
                        There’s a lot about this that in hindsight doesn’t add up, I’m afraid I was very impulsive in my worry for her, so I didn’t even consider these things until she’d left, and the deletion of messages happened. I’m not sure why either, my only explanation is that she threatened to walk out or worse, so he agreed to her demand to leave and come here.

                        That’s why the context of this being a first time for him physically abusing her makes sense I think, this is not a regular occurrence, not from him.

                      • #66010 Reply
                        User_4b1016e7
                        Participant
                          U
                          User_4b1016e7
                          PARTICIPANT
                          January 26, 2025 at 7:47 pm
                          OP is a lady

                      • #66003 Reply
                        User_eaafee9a
                        Participant
                          U
                          User_eaafee9a
                          PARTICIPANT
                          January 26, 2025 at 9:30 pm
                          Are you rich by any chance?

                          • #66009 Reply
                            User_eaafee9a
                            Participant
                              U
                              User_eaafee9a
                              PARTICIPANT
                              January 26, 2025 at 9:31 pm
                              How come only she took pics?? Didn’t you take any pics??

                          • #66002 Reply
                            Bravethinker9505
                            Participant
                              B
                              Bravethinker9505
                              PARTICIPANT
                              January 27, 2025 at 1:47 am
                              I think you are overthinking this, honestly not much you can do at the moment. Let her go and sit tight. Also seems her father has a lot of more primal issues to deal with – he most probably won’t come after you.

                              If your parents are in this and you guys are okay to spend a bit – speak to a lawyer to just safeguard your interests.

                            • #66001 Reply
                              User_c9b48aa7
                              Participant
                                U
                                User_c9b48aa7
                                PARTICIPANT
                                January 27, 2025 at 4:38 am
                                NAL but
                                1) stop overthinking 2) remove her name in contacts and back up the conversation with mobile number JIC

                              • #66000 Reply
                                User_053fdf0c
                                Participant
                                  U
                                  User_053fdf0c
                                  PARTICIPANT
                                  January 27, 2025 at 8:36 am
                                  NAL. She probably deleted the entire conversation from her phone so that her family doesn’t see it – which is important for her safety. But your chats won’t go from your phone unless you delete it with the “delete for everyone” option. I think you’re overthinking that part. I suggest you take screenshots, and if you have chat backups then get the backup (with the full conversation) and save it somewhere safe. This is if things escalate in future and either you or she needs evidence. Don’t delete from your end I would suggest – her father can’t see your phone so he can’t hurt you.

                                  It does sound weird that he dropped her off at your place, but she may have lied that you’re studying/working together in order to get away from the house and he dropped her personally to make sure she didn’t go to the police etc.

                                  My suggestion is that you speak to her properly about what’s happening the next time you meet her privately, and keep your chats with her safe – that is, if someone in her family sees them, she shouldn’t get into trouble. Just let her know you’re available for her in case she needs to reach out, without actually saying that – may be random reels or random messages that are common for two friends to share without raising any concerns.

                                  Abusers wouldn’t usually want to let the world know what they’re doing, so the threat is for her I think, I doubt they’ll want anything to do with you. Your friend on the other hand needs you – see how you can help her without triggering more abuse from the family.

                              Viewing 9 reply threads
                              Reply To: Friend has an abusive family, I gave her a place to stay for one day
                              Your information: