Question on RECOVERY OF JOINING BONUS

Community Forums Legal Advice India Question on RECOVERY OF JOINING BONUS

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    Posts
    • #52052 Reply
      User_e9781af3
      Participant
        U
        User_e9781af3
        PARTICIPANT
        February 17, 2025 at 10:30 pm
        I joined a company in 2024 which said they will give me a joining bonus of 85,000 INR along with my 1st salary and if I leave the company within 12 months , I will have to return the joining bonus.

        The twist is, due to delay in Approval they credited joining bonus along with my 2nd salary (not 1st salary) and I left the organization within 12 months.

        The clause on offer letter states –

        You will also receive a one-time cash payment of INR 85000/- less applicable withholdings and deductions and payable as part of the first salary processed post joining the company. This payment is contingent upon your agreeing to refund this payment as part of your full and final obligations to the company, in the event that you have (1) voluntarily resigned, (2) given notice of your voluntary resignation or (3) been subject to disciplinary dismissal prior to one year from D0J.

        Genuine question –
        1) On the verbiage it is mentioned one time CASH payment, does it really mean they have to pay me in cash or will be credited to my bank account? because it got credit with my 2nd salary

        2) The one time bonus I received with my 2nd Salary and NOT with my 1st salary as mentioned in the verbiage/clause. Now Since the clause was not fully adhered to as per the agreed terms, does the refund obligation still applies.

        As proof I have salary slip which shows that on the 2nd salary cycle after joining I received the joining bonus.

      • #52053 Reply
        Saratseeker418
        Participant
          S
          Saratseeker418
          PARTICIPANT
          February 17, 2025 at 11:24 pm
          Cash in a business transaction refers to money not currency. The clause means that 85000 will be paid as money and not as a benefit.

          By accepting the money and not complaining about the delay you have implicitly condoned the delay if there was one.

          • #52054 Reply
            User_e9781af3
            Participant
              U
              User_e9781af3
              OP
              February 18, 2025 at 5:13 am
              SO due to the delay I had escalated the issue and I was informed that this is due to delay in approval process. Since they did not adhere to the clause of crediting it with my 1st salary, can the employee disregard the second part of the clause?

              • #52055 Reply
                Saratseeker418
                Participant
                  S
                  Saratseeker418
                  PARTICIPANT
                  February 18, 2025 at 5:26 am
                  My dear sir, how many salaries have been credited since then ? After taking the money you want to retain it alleging non compliance that too after a long period. The maximum relief any court may grant is interest on the delay. Is the reason stated in your resignation as the primary factor in exiting? Stop watching legal shows where a lawyer miraculously arrives at a favourable outcome by a complicated sleight of hand.

                  • #52056 Reply
                    User_e9781af3
                    Participant
                      U
                      User_e9781af3
                      OP
                      February 19, 2025 at 12:34 am
                      I was terminated by the employer and it was an involuntary termination.

            Viewing 1 reply thread
            Reply To: Question on RECOVERY OF JOINING BONUS
            Your information: