Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
CYou cannot refuse to give your testimony before the court during trial. The police naturally needs your assistance before the court process as well to find the culprit and produce them before the court. If your testimony is essential, the prosecution and even the defence lawyers can get summons issued to request your presence in court. Refusing to appear when summons are issued can lead to fines being levied and it is also seen as a contempt of court.
Please don’t think of it as a burden rather a way to help the family of the victim and also, the society in general by getting rid of the criminals and ensuring people’s trust in the legal process.
CIn such situations, the very specifics of how and what was done, the extent of injury caused and how exactly is the death caused, matters. Because, it will come down to showing the intent of the action done by the victim. And to prove intent in court, obviously no one can read minds, it is shown through circumstantial evidence which is why what exactly happened, will determine it.For example, if you use the knife, you may not intend to kill but it stabs right in the heart, it’ll be extremely difficult to prove that you didn’t intend to kill, but let’s say you just slash it, it cuts the wrist of the attacker and then he bleeds to death in sometime, easier to prove that you didn’t intend to kill. However, it is to be kept in mind that if at all death is caused, it’ll be a difficult case nonetheless and can very well depend on the prosecution and defence lawyers and the judge, how it is interpreted and if any punishment is awarded.
CPepper spray is legal, yes. Bat is not a weapon per se so legal to carry, but I doubt anyone would be just randomly carrying it around for this purpose, it’s heavy lol. I’m not sure about the small blade knife, it may be legal, if yes, then it can be used in line with how I described in my previous comment.CLawyer here, as per the penal code (the new BNS), you can of course act in self defence but as others have pointed out, there are limits to the extent you can use self defence to hurt or critically injure the other person.If someone is staring at you, I’m afraid you can’t do anything to that person physically, other than call him out publicly, move away yourself or just inform any authority/cop that he’s staring and making you uncomfortable.
If, however, someone gropes you, you are well within your rights to physically attack that person but with you bare hands. You can twist their hands, punch/kick them, push them, however, none of these can be lethal moves which you knowingly executed to kill that person. That would be beyond the scope of self defence. However, if let’s say you push them away, they fall back and their head hits a stone and they die, that would not be your fault and in most cases you would get away with it. But if you knowingly hit them in a spot, in a manner, where it’s likely that they’ll die (probably because you know martial arts or something and know critical spots) then you’ll be charged with culpable homicide not amounting to murder. Remember that all this was using your bare hands.
With weapons however, it’s a different ball game. Firstly, carrying a lethal weapon like a knife or a gun itself is a bit problematic on your part, at least in India (unless you’re licensed to have a gun on your person). If, however, you do have it on you and someone gropes you, best you can do is pull out your weapon and threaten them and in most cases any sane person who was just there to grope you (and not planned an abduction or worse) would back away immediately which is what law would expect you to do. You can’t just directly stab someone or shoot them. The law wants you to allow yourself to be safe, not necessarily harm the attacker, that’s for the law to deal with and punish them.
Let’s say they back off once you pull out your weapon but they still come charging at you afterwards, then that is the point you may be allowed to use the weapon but again, you cannot target it at a vital spot where the other person will die soon. You can shoot at legs to stop them or at arm to maim them but not at chest or head. For a knife, you could slash it across hitting whatever comes in the way, but if you actually hold it straight and use motion to actively stab the person in a vital spot then that won’t be right.
Hope that helps, let me know if you have any follow ups. Also, keep in mind that this is theoretical supplemented by some practical experience. Each and every case is different on their own and the outcome can depend on dozens of factors.
