Ranjanstar700

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Received wrong payment of 5 lakhs in my bank account #18149
    Ranjanstar700
    Participant
      R
      Ranjanstar700
      PARTICIPANT
      April 10, 2025 at 7:20 am
      You should email them memorialising what happened — the call, its contents, the request, etc. Say that this money ought to be returned to the payer and that the bank has your consent to this end.

      in reply to: Liability of son to clear fathers debt #21285
      Ranjanstar700
      Participant
        R
        Ranjanstar700
        PARTICIPANT
        April 4, 2025 at 10:27 am
        No, that is wrong. Even if there is truly any ancestral property—which has been in the family without partition for four or more generations without partition—OP will not be liable for anything. The property may become affected to the extent of his father’s prospective share in it and no more.

        in reply to: Liability of son to clear fathers debt #21284
        Ranjanstar700
        Participant
          R
          Ranjanstar700
          PARTICIPANT
          April 4, 2025 at 8:49 am
          You are not legally liable for your father’s debt. You will not have any legal action. Your father can face proceedings for recovery of the debt. He may be proceeded against in criminal court under NI Act for bounced cheques or EMI auto debit instructions if any. There are other criminal-law provisions that I will not get into because they are usually not invoked and I can’t state anything definitively.

          Ranjanstar700
          Participant
            R
            Ranjanstar700
            PARTICIPANT
            March 25, 2025 at 6:56 am
            Have you inherited anything from your father? If you have not then you are not liable for his debt. Send them an email or letter explaining that your father is no more, you’re not liable for his debt, and want the bank officials to stop harassing you (or you will take legal action). Break contact with the banks at this point if you are not liable. If they harass you, file an online complaint with the banking ombudsman. It is unlikely they will proceed further, eventually losing interest given the small sums. They may institute arbitration on their own (think of it as a private court). But it will in all likelihood be invalid in law as they end up appointing arbitrators on their own. Besides they will in all likelihood arbitrate in your father’s name which will be invalid (any suit or proceeding after a person’s death must be brought against their heirs).

            in reply to: Bank says pay loan or we will throw you out of the house. #53246
            Ranjanstar700
            Participant
              R
              Ranjanstar700
              PARTICIPANT
              February 16, 2025 at 8:28 am
              The most elementary analysis requires documents. Was this really an ancestral property? How was the part in question transferred? Is that transfer valid? Was there fraud or misrepresentation that led to the transfer? Has there been a partition? Based on the answer you could issue appropriate proceedings to protect your parents’ rights. But anyone wanting to advise you properly will have to look at documents.

              Ranjanstar700
              Participant
                R
                Ranjanstar700
                PARTICIPANT
                February 10, 2025 at 6:55 am
                I presume you’re referring to the question re anti-suit injunctions. I’m simply asking if the commenter knows about that. I brought it up because they seem to think you can have a sneaky divorce in the US behind your souse’s back. It doesn’t work that way.

                Ranjanstar700
                Participant
                  R
                  Ranjanstar700
                  PARTICIPANT
                  February 10, 2025 at 6:49 am
                  I agree. I tried saying essentially the same thing in my comment and got downvoted. It is important OP and other similarly situated litigants are protected from anecdotal projections that so often masquerade as legal advice here. This is an involved branch of private international law which in turn is complicated to begin with.

                  Ranjanstar700
                  Participant
                    R
                    Ranjanstar700
                    PARTICIPANT
                    February 10, 2025 at 6:41 am
                    You clearly don’t know the “P” of private international law or the “D” of domicile. Ever heard of anti-suit injunction? Know courts of one country can refuse to recognise the decree of another? Of course you do not.

                    Ranjanstar700
                    Participant
                      R
                      Ranjanstar700
                      PARTICIPANT
                      February 10, 2025 at 5:58 am
                      You should get divorced in India. It is preferable to the US for legal reasons. You’re both likely domiciled in India (domicile, habitual residence and citizenship are different). However, this is a particularly involved aspect of private international law. I (or another) private international law practitioner will need more details before they can advise you more fully — re your marriage, any children, assets, etc. The end game is to get a divorce decree that is recognised everywhere. You’re both domiciled don’t want a zombie marriage — one dissolved in the U.S. but abiding in India. PS: And trust me you don’t want to listen to generic advice here. Private international law is not as straightforward as some think it is.

                      in reply to: A lawyer’s rant based in Delhi. #60673
                      Ranjanstar700
                      Participant
                        R
                        Ranjanstar700
                        PARTICIPANT
                        February 6, 2025 at 5:52 am
                        This may be misfeasance in public office. I remember getting those calls with a spam warning which meant I hung up as soon as I heard “BJP” and “lawyers meet.”

                        Ranjanstar700
                        Participant
                          R
                          Ranjanstar700
                          PARTICIPANT
                          January 31, 2025 at 12:11 am
                          Ask her to get that divorce and then some. Assuming what you have said is true, she shouldn’t be putting up with this.

                        Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)