Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
SHi lawyer here too, can you give me the reference judgements of SC after which HCs stopped giving staySMy point exactly, enjoy the reservation (because discrimination) lollipop while actual reformative laws and measures are snatched right out of the hands of the poor and backward classesSReally ? have a look at developed countries, tell me how many years of reservations they had for their poor and backward classes
The only point I am trying to make so far is that reservation has no correlation with discrimination, but if you are not willing to accept that submission, there is nothing I can do about it
SI never said that, all I pointed out is reservation is useless, you take my statements out of context and give provocative repliesSReservation? It wont, thats what my original reply wasBut perhaps op can look into relevant provisions of the sc st act which has laws against discrimination, the same law where some people from infosys are facing discrimination lawsuits
SNot sure who you are referring to, but all I said was reservation doesnt really help against caste discrimination, nobody ever claimed that backward classes are ambani level richSGreat, then let the quotas like ews persist and remove the caste based quotas, the problem solves itselfSI gave the solution already, reservation benefits should be given on basis of poverty status rather than caste, it would solve the problemSIf reservation was effective, then they wouldn’t be the poorest communities, would they?I agree that the metro view does not reflect ground reality in the rest of the country, so maybe reservation should be made applicable in only those areas where these poor communities exist then? Would it help then? Do you see the picture now?
SThen reservation should be on the basis of poverty and not caste, correct?Otherwise it merely becomes preferential treatment
SNo it doesnt, people treating you like an asshole should not allow you to get employment and/or selection benefits over others
